This is a digital copy of a book that was preserved for generations on library shelves before it was carefully scanned by Google as part of a project to make the world's books discoverable online.

It has survived long enough for the copyright to expire and the book to enter the public domain. A public domain book is one that was never subject to copyright or whose legal copyright term has expired. Whether a book is in the public domain may vary country to country. Public domain books are our gateways to the past, representing a wealth of history, culture and knowledge that's often difficult to discover.

Marks, notations and other marginalia present in the original volume will appear in this file - a reminder of this book's long journey from the publisher to a library and finally to you.

Usage guidelines

Google is proud to partner with libraries to digitize public domain materials and make them widely accessible. Public domain books belong to the public and we are merely their custodians. Nevertheless, this work is expensive, so in order to keep providing this resource, we have taken steps to prevent abuse by commercial parties, including placing technical restrictions on automated querying.

We also ask that you:

+ Make non-commercial use of the files We designed Google Book Search for use by individuals, and we request that you use these files for personal, non-commercial purposes.

+ Refrain from automated querying Do not send automated queries of any sort to Google's system: If you are conducting research on machine translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a large amount of text is helpful, please contact us. We encourage the use of public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help.

+ Maintain attribution The Google "watermark" you see on each file is essential for informing people about this project and helping them find additional materials through Google Book Search. Please do not remove it.

+ Keep it legal Whatever your use, remember that you are responsible for ensuring that what you are doing is legal. Do not assume that just because we believe a book is in the public domain for users in the United States, that the work is also in the public domain for users in other countries. Whether a book is still in copyright varies from country to country, and we can't offer guidance on whether any specific use of any specific book is allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearance in Google Book Search means it can be used in any manner anywhere in the world. Copyright infringement liability can be quite severe.

About Google Book Search

Google's mission is to organize the world's information and to make it universally accessible and useful. Google Book Search helps readers discover the world's books while helping authors and publishers reach new audiences. You can search through the full text of this book on the web

at|http : //books . google . com/

. i ■.1.-.* 'i ^-r-

amU'n.A'hr. M.a-r.jy/WmuirU, .5i>»K.A/.; ^;.?

HISTORY .

OF

THE CAPTIVITY OF MPOLEON

AT ST. HELENA;

FROM THE LETTERS AND JOURNALS

OV THE LATE

LIEUT. -GEN. SIR HUDSON LOWE,

OFFICIAl DOCUMESTS NOT BEFORE MADE PUBLIC.

Br WILLIAM FORSYTH, M.A.,

Avmat or ' Botmrnwu' ahd 'imroBT of ibial nr nrcr.' L&n wrnuMw or TBimrr ooluor, oakbxidoi.

IN THREE VOLUMES.— Vol. I. wut^ ^ofliuU unit piap.

LONDON: JOHN MURRAY, ALBEMARLE STREET.

1853.

The AiMor retenm to hinaelf the rigU of mlhonmng a Traiuiation of (Ki» 'Wor*.

-?\^

^c^

^

UOMDOM : PSIIVTED BT If. CU>irE8 AHD 80MS, STTAMFOBD STKEET.

PREFACE.

When Mr. Murray first proposed to place in my hands the papers of the late Sir Hudson Lowe in order that I might undertake the present work, after some consideration I declined the task, chiefly on grounds of a professional nature. For the Law is a jealous mistress, and recognises no half-hearted or divided allegiance. But the proposal was again pressed upon me in so flattering a manner, that I was induced to reconsider my decision. I reflected that the subject was one for the due treatment of which my profession in some degree qualified me, as the value of the work must mainly depend upon the mode in which evidence is handled, and conflicting state ments are discussed. The habit which a Lawyer acquires of sifting evidence, is one which he may use- fully apply in the solution of historical questions, as well as in forensic disputes. But he must be on his guard, and remember that he betrays the office of an Historian if he assumes the tone of an Advocate. When I commenced the present volumes, I made as it were a covenant with myself, that I would, in the

a 2

iv PREFACE.

language of our courts, "well and truly try the ques- tion at issue between the parties, and a true verdict give according to the evidence." I was not asked to make out a case for Sir Hudson Lowe, nor, had I been asked to do so, would I have consented. I re- garded the duty of examining the papers left by him as a solemn trust for the due and truthful discharge of which I was responsible to the public, and a still more searching tribunal, nay own conscience. Amicus SocrateSy amicus Plato, sed magis arnica Veritas.

The present narrative has been written amidst the claims of a laborious profession, during the periods which otherwise would have been given to relaxation. I do not say this to deprecate criticism, for it is un- doubtedly true that no author ought voluntarily to undertake what he does not think he can feirly exe- cute. I merely state the feet.

As to the style and manner in which I have per- formed the task it is not for me to judge. That ques- tion will be decided by the public for themselves, and every writer must submit himself to their impar- tial opinion, from which there is no appeal. But I do claim for myself the right to be believed when I assert that the present volumes have been written with the most minute and scrupulous regard to truth. I had to deal with an enormous mass of papers^ and selection and curtailment were inevitable ; but I have not kept back one single feet or expression which, whether it told for the one side or the other, could by possibility throw light upon the great question at issue. And for this reason I have sometimes intro-

PREFACE. V

duoed matter which might well have been omittesji, if my sole object had been to interest or amuse the reader, and not to state the whole case* The reader will not ML to observe inaccuracies of expression and mistakes of grammar in the letters and documents quoted, but I did not think myself at liberty to make any alteration for the purpose of correction, except now and then with respect to some mere clerical error. I have used the orthography "Bonaparte," although there is no doubt that the name was origin- ally and properly written "Buonaparte;" but Napo- leon dropped the u, and modem usage has sanctioned the change.^ Lord Bathurst, in his correspondence with Sir Hudson Lowe, usually wrote "Buonaparte," but sometimes "Bonaparte" or "Bonaparte."

If the language in which I have frequently spoken of O'Meara seems severe, let the reader, before it is OHMlemned, consider whether it has not been deserved. I am not one of those who think that such conduct as he has been guilty of in slandering others may be sufficiently censured in the dulcet tones of gentle animadversion- He merits a sterner and more fear- less judgment. Such writers are the pests of litera- ture. They corrupt the stream of history by poisoning its fountains, and the effect of his work has been to mislead aU succeeding authors, and perpetuate a tale of fiklsehood.

As regards Napoleon, if I know anything of myself, my sympathies were in his favour. I cannot

* See on this subject O'Meara's * Voice from St. Helena,' vol. ii. p, 93, and * Quarterly Beview/ vol. xxviii. p. 254,

Vi PREFACE.

now safficiently express my admiration of his genius ; but neither can I blind myself to the fact that he did not exhibit in misfortune that magnanimity without which there is no real greatness, and that he concen- trated the energies of his mighty intellect on tJie ignoble task of insulting the Governor of St. Helena and manufacturing a case of hardship and oppression for himself. I have endeavoured to hold the balance even, and it is not the weight of prejudice, but of fitcts, which has made one of the scales preponderate. Let me now say a few words respecting the mate- rials I have used. And here I cannot do better than quote the late Sir Hudson Lowe's own account of the papers in his possession, which he drew up when he contemplated a publication of them in his lifetime ; a design, however, which, unfortunately for his reputa- tion, he foiled to execute. He says, — " There are perhaps few, if any, public administrations of any kind, of which the records are so full and complete as those of my Government at St. Helena. There is not only a detailed correspondence addressed to the proper department of His Majesty's Government, reporting the occurrences of almost every day during the five years that Napoleon Bonaparte remained under my custody, but the greater part of the conversations held with Bonaparte himself, or with his followers, was immediately noted down with an ability and exact- ness which reflect the highest credit on my Military Secretary [Major Gorrequer]. This gentleman was not only a perfect master of the French language, but possessed a memory equally remarkable for its

PREFACE. Vii

accuracy and tenacity, and was therefore eminently qualified to report the conversations at which he was himself present, and to detect any error to which a misapprehension of the meaning of foreigners might lead other persons who repeated what passed at inter- views with Bonaparte and his followers/'

I have had access to a vast number of original de- spatches of Earl Bathnrst, who was Secretary of State for the Colonies while Napoleon was at St. Helena, and to the originals or copies of every important docnment connected with the subject. Thirty folio volumes are filled with copies of correspondence and other writings, carefiilly made under the direction of Sir Hudson Lowe, who seems to have treasured a memorial of almost every incident, however trivial, connected with that important period of his life. In addition to these, there are several large boxes which contain manuscripts, chiefly copies, relating to the same events, all of which have been diligently exa- mined for the purpose of the present work. Two sets of copies of 0*Meara's letters to Mr. Finlaison, so frequently quoted in the narrative, were placed in my hands ; but I wish distinctly to state that I have not seen the originals. One of these sets was made officially at the time when the letters were communi- cated through the Admiralty to the Cabinet, as will be explained in the course of the narrative, and their correctness cannot for a moment be doubted.

It only remains that I should make an acknowledg- ment for the assistance I have received. The Lowe papers were originally placed, some years ago, in the

VUl PKEFACE.

hands of the late Sir Harris Nicolas, with a view to publication under his auspices as editor. He under- went the heavy labour of arranging them, and before his death had proceeded so far as to have a volu* mmous mass of documents set up in type, down to the date of September, 1817, His plan, however, was to print almost every letter and other manuscript at full length in chronological order, connecting them with a slender thread of explanatory remark. The consequence would have been that if his plan had been carried out the work must have consisted of ei^t or nine closely printed octavo volumes, the price of which would have rendered them inaccessible to the public generally. Moreover, the interest of the subject was suffocated under a mass of minute detail, which would have bewildered the attention and exhausted the patience of the reader. I, there- fore, after full consideration, resolved to re-write the work, and adopt a wholly different plan. I thought that the only mode of doing justice to the importance of the subject was to make use of the letters and documents as materials for the narrative, and treat them as the hewn stones out of which the fabric of a history was to be constructed, instead of piling them in a heap with little regard to architectural sym- metry and effect. But I most willingly and gladly admit my obligations to Sir Harris Nicolas in having gone through the drudgery of a thorough examination of the papers, the mere sight of which was enough to appal a writer and deter him from undertaking the task of editing them. His labours have greatly

PREFACE. IX

assisted and lightened mine, nor do I know that I shonld have had the conrage to commence the work if he had not payed the way by rendering the materials more manageable under my hands. Moreover, I am much indebted to him for the carefiil collation he had made of references and authorities, in which I have generally found him scrupulously correct. I thought that the public would rather have a history than a mere collection of documents, but that in a work like this, which must challenge hostile criticism on the part of those who are determined to believe the calumnies which have so long had currency respecting the captivity of Napoleon, they would require to see in extenso all the documents of importance which sup- port the views put forward in the narrative. These, therefore, are published at the end of each of the present volumes, and may be considered as the Pieces JusHJicatives of the history.

I must also thank Lieutenant-Colonel Jackson, Professor of Military Surveying at the East India CoU^e at Addiscombe, for his ready and obliging willingness to give me every information in his power respecting events in which he was an actor, and re- specting persons of whom he is now one of the very few survivors. In conclusion I can only express my earnest hope that this work may be the means of rectifying some erroneous views, and enabling the public to fonn a just opinion respecting one of the most in- teresting episodes of history. I^ will be to me a source of sincere and lasting satisfaction if I have, with the most rigid adherence to truth, and by the

VOL. I. 6

X PREFACE.

mere force of fisicts, snoceeded in TiBdicating tlie Bie- mory of those who have been long calumniated, and proving that neither the British Qoyenunent nor Sir Hudson Lowe was in fimlt as regards the treatment of Kapoleon at St, Helena.

Tm^ Ua^ 185a.

%

( « )

CONTENTS OF TOL L

CHAPTER I.

PAQS

SoTTCTder of Napoleon Boiui|Nirt« to tiM Brttish Oovntmnent^ snd hu arrival at Si. Helena 1

CHAPTEB IL

St Helena — The Brian — Longwood — Correspondence of Sir Greorge Cod^bom with Counts Montholon and Bertrand — Olfeate 26

CHAPTEB m.

Memoir of Sir Hudson Lowe up to the period of his hecoming Go- ▼emor of St Helena 85

CHAPTER IV.

First interview of Sir Hudson Lowe with Bonaparte — Difficulty in getting the French offioers to sign the declaration —Other inter- views with Bonaparte — Letters of O'Meara to Sir Thomas Beade and others 138

CHAPTER V.

Arrival of Bear-Admiral Sir Pulteney Malcolm and the foreign Commisnoners — Proclamation by the (Governor — Madame Bertrand's note to the Marquis de Montchenu — Question of Napoleon's residence and expenses of his establishment — Inter- view between him and the Governor — Sir Hudson Lowe's Despatches to England .189

Xll CONTENTS OP VOL. I.

CHAFTEB VI.

Pao«

0'Meara*8 letters to Sir Thomas Reade — Complaints respecting provisions — Qaestion of reduction of expenses at Loogwood — Sir Hudson Lowe's last interview with Kapoleon — Letter of remonstrance from Count Montholon, and comments by the Governor — Correspondence on the subject of passes to Long- wood signed by Count Bertrand 234

CHAFTEB Vn.

Reduction of expenses at Longwood — Plate broken up for sale — Beal object of this — Letters of Olfeara — Despatches from Lord Bathurst — Olfeara's correspondence with Mr. Finlaison at the Admiralty — Liformation given of projects for Napoleon's escape — Refusal of Napoleon to see Sir Hudson Lowe — Inter- views of Sir Thomas Reade with Bonaparte and Count Bertrand . 279

CHAFTEB Vin.

Objections of the French to signing the declaration — Alterations made by Sir Hudson Lowe in the regulations — Proposal of Bonaparte to assume another name — Interview between the Governor and Count Bertrand on the subject — Napoleon on the New Testament — His criticism on the battle of Waterloo — Letter from O^Meara to Mr. IB^laison, and his description of the style of living at Longwood — More plate broken up, and Mon- tholon's account of the stratagem — Calumny of CMeaia . . 322

CHAPTER IX. Discovery of clandestine conespondencey and arrest of Las Cases . 367

LETTERS and DOCUMENTS, in the nature of Pboofs and

iLLUffTRATlONS 396

HISTORY

OF THS

CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEOK

CHAPTER I.

SURRENDER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE TO THE BRmSH QOVERNMENT, AND HIS ARRIVAL AT ST. HELENA.

At a time when one of the family of Bonaparte is again seated on the throne of France, and the Empire has been once more proclaimed in that country of poli- tical revolutions, fresh interest is awakened in the history of him who was the founder of the dynasty, and to the magic of whose name the present ruler of the French owes his elevation to the Lnperial dignity. The period therefore is not inopportune for giving to the world a true narrative of the laat six years of the life of ^Napoleon, which he spent, as the prisoner of England and the Allied Powers, on an island rock in the midst of the Atlantic, when the fetbric of his power had been shattered at Waterloo, and he was compelled to seek refuge on board a British man of war, and throw himself into the hands of those whom he described as " the most powerful, the most constant, and the most ^^ generous of his enemies."

I say emphatically a true narrative; for hitherto the story of Napoleon^s captivity has been told by writers whose object was not to make known the truth, but to exalt the character of their hero and depreciate

VOL. T. B

*% : :/: 'V: :'*.*:' •CATyrvlt? op napoleon. Chap, i.

that of Sir Hudson Lowe. O'Meara, Las Cases, Mon- tholon, and Antommarchi, who were the immediate attendants of the exile at Longwood, who were eye- witnesses of the treatment he received, and on whose statements, therefore, the opinion of the public mainly rests, had each a separate cause of quarrel with the late Grovemor of St. Helena. O'Meara attributed to him his removal from the post of physician to Napoleon, and dimissal from the navy by the English Grovem- ment for conduct at utter variance with his duty. This rankled in his heart, and his book bears in every page the mark of implacable hatred against those who were the authors of his disgrace. But of him we shall speak more at length hereafter, and show, by evidence that cannot be disputed, that his * Voice from St. Helena ' is a voice wholly unworthy of belief. Las Cases also was sent away from the island by the Go- vernor for infringing the rules laid down to ensure the safe custody of Napoleon : and in his * Journal ' he has perverted almost every feet which he records, for the purpose of vilifying the one, and exalting by contrast the character of the other. He did not hesitate to avow that the Emperor was the god of his idolatry, and at that shrine he thought it little to sacrifice the reputation of the officer to whose keeping his master was committed, with whom he himself came in collision, and who, in the execution of his duty, could not but give ofiTence to minds so irritated and susceptible as those of the inmates of Longwood. We shall see the estimate which Napoleon and O'Meara themselves formed of the veracity of Montholon ; and it is too much to assume that when the supposed inte- rests of the fallen Emperor were at stake he would be more scrupulous in his subsequent writings than in his language at the time when the events which he pro-

Chap. I. HISTORIANS OF THE CAPTIVITY. 3

fesses to record occarred. As to Antommarchi, his amovT^opre had been offended by his being subjected to the same regulations as the French residents at Longwood, and also by the earnestness with which Sir Hudson Lowe pressed upon the attendants of Napoleon the necessity of having recourse to addi- tional medical advice when his illness became serious.

The period, however, has arrived when a just and impartial verdict may be given. We have now the means of knowing the facts as they really happened, and we are too fer removed from the era to which they relate to be influenced by the feelings which agitated the minds of the men of that generation. The tomb has closed over almost all the great actors in the struggle. The passions arising from the long conflict in which England was engaged have died away. Party has no longer any object to serve in making the treatment of Napoleon an engine of political attack, and we may hope that in this country, at all events, the public will be disposed to take a calm and unprejudiced view of events, the account of which has been hitherto given with little regard to the stem fidelity which is the first duty of the historian.

There are indeed some persons to whom a refutation of charges once believed is addressed in vain. Having taken the pains to form an opinion, they cling to it as a first principle, which admits of neither question nor dispute. Their minds are no longer open to conviction, for prejudice has closed every avenue through which trutii can enter. With such it is in vain to argue. No amount of evidence is suflBcient to alter the fore- gone conclusion at which they have perhaps not unwill- ingly arrived.^ They have made up their minds that

> <* Ambitionem scriptoris facile adveneris ; obtrectatio et livor pronis anribuB acdpiiintur.'* — Tadtui,

6 2

4 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. I.

Sir Hudson Lowe was a tyrant and Napoleon his victim, and they refuse to listen when they are told that it can be proved to demonstration that the asser- tion is untrue. These are the reasoners to whom the great satirist of antiquity alludes when he makes one of his characters exclaim, "Although you persuade me, I will not be persuaded/* In daily life we all know how difficult it is to free ourselves from suspicion of a man who has once been assailed by calumny, however groundless the calumny may be. The correction of error requires a degree of labour which few persons care to take. It is as true now as it was when the Greek historian wrote, that the generality of men will not give themselves trouble in search of truth, but content themselves with what happens first to come to hand.^

And what has been the nature of the proofs upon which the question of the conduct of the British Go- vernment and of Sir Hudson Lowe towards Napoleon has been allowed to rest ?

The Chinese have a proverb that " No lies are so wicked as those which have a foundation in truth/* And the reason of this is obvious. A direct and naked falsehood can seldom be supported. It has no element of vitality, and after answering a temporary purpose dies from mere inanition. It is capable of a short and positive contradiction, and convincing proof can gene- rally be given promptly and without difficulty to show that it i5 a falsehood. But the case is very diflFerent with ingenious distortions of fact. A caricature must preserve some of the features of the portrait, or it would fail in its purpose. It would cease to be a caricature, for no one would recognise the resemblance. And so

' *' Zvrvs in'oXaiir^pos roU itoXXols if Hrpvtt rijt &Ai76c(as, Koi hrl r& h-otfia ftMWoy Tp^ovrai." — Thucydides.

Chap. I. THE LONGWOOD POLICY. 5

in descriptions of events and details of conversations. By dexterous additions and omissions, by transpositions of dates, by alterations, "here a little and there a little," an effect may be produced quite opposite to the truth, and yet it may require far more care and thought and attention than the great mass of readers are willing or able to bestow, to unravel the web, and separate the threads of falsehood which have been skilfully shot through the tissue of the narrative. I shall show, indeed, that the writers to whom I have alluded did not shrink from resorting at times to wilful untruth, but their chief weapon has been mis- representation. In a suppressed passage of Count Las Cases' Journal, under the date of November 30, 1815, he says,^ " We had nothing left us but moral weapons ; that to make the most effective use of these, it was necessary to reduce to a system our demeanour, our words, our sentiments, evten our privations ; that a large population in Europe would take a lively inte- rest in our behalf; that the Opposition in England would not fail to attack the Ministry on the violence of their conduct towards us."^ The policy at Long- wood was a policy of deception and intrigue. It was a desperate attempt by Napoleon to create sufficient sympathy in Europe to render probable the chance of his removal from his ocean prison, and to attain this end no calumny was deemed too gross — no misrepre-

* The circumstances under which the original manuscript of Las Cases' Journal came into the possession of Sir Hudson Lowe, who was thus enahled to have an exact copy taken, will be detailed hereafter.

• ** Qu'il ne nous restait que des armes morales ; que pour en faire I'usage le plus avantageux, 11 fallait reduire en systeme notre attitude, nos paroles, nofl sentimens, nos privationa rnhfies ; qu*une nombreuse population en Europe prendrait une tendre int^rfit en nous ; que Topposition en Angleterre ne manqtierait pas de combattre le ministfere dans la violence qu'ils ont exerc^ contre nous.**

6 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. T.

sentation was thought too mean. " My good friend," said General Montholon one day to Lieutenant (now Lieutenant-Colonel) Jackson, at St, Helena, who told him that Sir Hudson Lowe had refrained from ap- pointing him orderly ofl&cer at Longwood out of delicacy to Napoleon because he was then only a lieutenant — "My good friend, you have had a for- tunate escape; for had you come hither as an or- derly officer we would most assuredly have ruined your reputation. It is a part of ovr system^ et que voulez vous dire?'' Does not this sentence speak volumes ?

From a French writer we might naturally expect on this subject nothing but panegyric upon Napoleon and invective agamst Sir Hudson Lowe.^ One author of that nation, however, has honourably distinguished himself by the impartial tone in which he has criticised the conduct of the Governor and his captive. Lamar- tine has done homage to truth, and, so far as he had the means of forming a just judgment, has taken pains to arrive at it. He has fully penetrated the motives of Napoleon in keeping up his quarrel with Sir Hud- son Lowe, and, if he has formed a wrong estimate in some respects of the character of the latter and mis- construed his actions, we must remember that he was obliged to winnow out the facts of the case from the heap of calumny and falsehood with which the enemies of that officer have loaded his memory, and that he had not access to the materials which would have enabled him to correct in many points his opinion. In the following passage he thus speaks of the Governor of

^ It is almoet a point of honour with the French to believe all that is evil of Sir Hudson Lowe. He is the hits noire of their imagination. Thus, Victor Hugo, in his * Napoleon le Petit,' a philippic in which he exhausta invective against the author of the coup d*^tat of the 2nd of

Chap. L LAMARTINE'S OPINION. 7

St. Helena and Napoleon :^ — " He" (that is the latter) " pursned slowly and obstinately the suicide of his cap- tivity. The arrival at St. Helena of a new Grovemor, Sir Hudson Lowe, riveted more closely his voluntary chains. That Governor, whom the myrmidons of Na- poleon, and Napoleon himself attacked with groundless and passionate charges, such as the hallucinations of captivity alone could inspire, — treated by them as a petty constable and an assassin, — ^had neither criminal intent against his captive in his thoughts, nor insult towards the unfortunate in his heart. But, crushed under the load of responsibility which weighed on him lest he might suffer to escape the disturber whom Europe had given him to guard, narrow in his ideas, jealous in his regulations, nervously tenacious of forms, deficient in tact, and odious to his captives from the very nature of his functions, he wearied Napoleon with restrictions, superintendence, orders, visits, and even marks of respect. He soon imparted to the duties of the GrOvemor of the island and guardian of an Euro- pean hostage the appearance and rudeness of a gaoler. Nevertheless, although he may be reproached with impropriety, he cannot be charged with ill-usage. He was the occasion rather than the cause of the unhappy end of Napoleon. In reading with attention the cor- respondence and notes exchanged on every pretext between the attendants on Napoleon and Sir Hudson Lowe, one is confounded at the insults, the provoca- tions, and the invectives with which the captive and his friends outraged the Governor at every turn. Na-

Deoember, the present Emperor of France, thinks he attains the climax of Barcaan when he exclaiiDs " pire qne Hndson Lowe ! Hudson Lowe n'^tait qu'iin geolier, Hudson Lowe n'^tait qu'un bourreau : I'homme qui assassine y^tablement Napoldon, c'est Louis Bonaparte ; Hudson Lowe n'avait tu^ que sa vie, Louis Bonaparte tue sa gloire." ' Histoire de ]& Kestauiation, torn. yi. p. 416.

8 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. I.

poleon at that time sought to excite by cries of pain the pity of the English Parliament, and to famish a grievance to the speakers of the Opposition against the Ministry, in order to obtain a removal nearer to Eu- rope. The desire of provoking insults by insult, and of afterwards exhibiting these insults as crimes to the indignation of the Continent, and of making Sir Hud- son Lowe the Pilate of this Napoleonic Calvary, is plainly evident in all those letters."

No doubt the portrait of the Governor is here harshly drawn, and some of the particulars are incorrect. For instance, when Lamartine speaks of Sir Hudson Lowe wearying Napoleon with visits, he seems not to be aware, or to have forgotten, that during the whole of the six years of the captivity the Governor had only five interviews with his prisoner ; and that Napoleon rudely and discourteously refused, after insulting him to his face with the grossest language of abuse, to see or have any intercourse with him again. Nor was there anything in his conduct or demeanour, as the reader will see, which can justify the application to him of the odious epithet of gaoler. But this question will appear in its true light as our narrative proceeds, and we need not anticipate here the judgment which will be formed on the facts of the captivity.

There never was a question of greater moment and difficulty presented to the consideration of a Ministry than that which arose in July, 1815, when the British Government received the astounding intelligence that Napoleon Bonaparte had surrendered himself to Eng- land, and was then on board His Majesty's ship of war, the Bellerophon, in Torbay. How was he to be treated? in what character ought he to be received ? was he the prisoner or the guest of England ? was he to be

July, 1815. DIFFICULTY OF THE MINISTRY. 9

regarded as an outlaw, and dealt with as hostis humani generis?

Each of these views had its advocates. In truth it was a case without a precedent. The great lawyers of the day were at fiiult. It was in vain to search the works of writers on the Law of Nations, for experience had not supplied, nor imagination suggested, an instance in point. Sir WilUam Grant, Sir William Scott, Lord EUenborough the Lord Chief Justice, and Lord Eldon the Lord Chancellor of England, were consulted and gave conflicting opinions.^ That of the Lord Chancellor was, " that the case was not provided for by anything to be found in Grotius or Vattel, but that the law of self-preservation would justify the keeping of Napoleon under restraint in some distant region, where he should be treated with all indulgence compatible with a due regard for the peace of mankind."

Napoleon himself suggested the nearest parallel which history affords. "I come," he said, in his femous letter to the Prince Regent,^ "like Themis- tocles, to seek the hospitality of the British nation. I place myself under the protection of their laws." And at first sight it might appear that the conduct of Persia was more magnanimous than that of Eng-

* Lord Holland brought forward, on the 8th of April, 1816, a motion in the Hofuse of Lords for referring to the judges the question of the gtatus of Kapoleon Bonaparte, and our right to detain him as a prisoner. This was properly and successfully resisted by the Lord Chancellor (33 Pari. Deb., 1019). The question was clearly one of state policy, and not of municipal law ; but Ld|dEldon relied on a more conclusive reason, which was (hat, whateyer the^Mons of the judges might be, an Act of Parliament was necessary to i^fk^^lhe exigency of the case.

• " Royal Highn4«. — ^Exposed to the factions which divide my country, aod to the hostility ot^c greatest powers of Europe, I have closed my political career, and I come^ like Themistocles, to seek the hospitality of the British nation. I place myself under the protection of their laws, which I claim from your Royal Highness, as the most powerful, the most constant, and the most generous of my enemies.'*

10 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. I.

land. For the eastern monarch assigned three royal cities, Lampsacus, Myus, and Magnesia, for the sup- port of his fallen enemy, and lavished gifts upon him in profusion, while tve banished our former foe to a distant island in the Atlantic, and treated him there as a prisoner of war. But a moment's consideration will show that the cases were not similar. Themistocles did not surrender himself j/Za^ranfe beUo. Moreover, he claimed protection on the ground that his exile was owing to his zeal for the interests of Persia, and he oflFered to do further injury to Greece as the price of his asylum. It was not therefore generosity, but policy, which influenced the Persian king. He re- warded the past treachery of a bad citizen, and pur- chased the future service of a renegade. Napoleon could advance no plea of having betrayed his country for the sake of England, nor would England have stooped to bargain for his help against France had she needed it, and he had been base enough to oflfer it.

The whole question of right or wrong in the conduct of the British Government towards Napoleon turns upon the view taken of this matter. It is essential to determine what was his real position when he first set foot on board the Bellerophon. Was he a guest, un- invited indeed, but still a guest, and, as such, entitled by misfortune to claim the sacred rights of hospitality ? or was he an enemy brought at last to bay, who had been hemmed round by foes until he was compelled to choose one amongst them to whom he would surrender himself a prisoner of war ?

Napoleon always assumed that he ought to have been received and treated in the former character. When he heard that he was to be conveyed to St. Helena he drew up on board the Bellerophon a pro- test, in which he said, ** I hereby solemnly protest, in

July, 1815. WAS HE GUEST OR PRISONER? 11

the &ce of Heaven and mankind, against the violence that is done me, and the violation of my most sacred rights, in forcibly disposing of my person and liberty* I voluntarily came on board the Bellerophon. I am not the prisoner, I am the guest of England." And throughout his captivity he consistently maintained the same view. When he was at St. Helena he said that, if the Governor were to give him the whole of the island on condition that he would pledge his word not to attempt an escape, he would not accept it, because it would be equivaJent to the acknowledging himself a prisoner.^ But a claim is not a title. The &cts of the case cannot be altered because Bonaparte chose to put upon them an interpretation favourable to him- self. Now what are those &cts? Yanquished at Waterloo by the combined armies of tiie Allied Powers, he fled through Paris and reached Rochefort, from which port^ owing to the presence of British cruizers, he found escape by sea impossible. He might indeed have attempted to rekindle the war in the heart of France, and hazarded the chance of ano- ther battle with the broken fragments of his army, which, under the command of Grouchy, had retired behind the Loire, but this he saw was a hopeless scheme, and the idea was, after due consideration, abandoned. He might have surrendered himself to Austria, or Russia, or any other Power, rather than to , England ; but still it must have been surrender, for all Europe was arrayed against him. If he had fallen into tiie hands of the Prussians, it was the intention of Blucher to have him shot over the grave of the Due \ d'Enghien in the ditch of Vincennes.'* In truth, Na-

* Vcnoe from St. Helena, i. 371, 372.

■ This resolution of the stem old Field Marshal is placed heyond a doubt by the recent publication of Baron von Miiffling's * Memoirs,' where we

12 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. I.

poleon had merely the choice of the nation to which he must give himself up, and not of the mode in which he was to be disposed of by that nation. Nor is this proposition likely to be disputed amongst ourselves. Even those who most strongly opposed the detennina- tion to send Napoleon to St. Helena hardly ventured to contest our right to do so. In the protest drawn up by Lord Holland, and signed by himself and the Duke of Sussex, against the bill " for the more eflfectually detaining in custody Napoleon Bonaparte," he said, that ^^ to consign to distant exile and imprisonment a foreign and captive chief who after the abdication of his authority, relying on British generosity, had sur- rendered himself to us in preference to his other ene- mies, is unworthy of the magnanimity of a great country." It may have been unworthy of our " mag- nanimity " — that is a question to be determined by a just and dispassionate view of the exigenci^ of the case — ^but we were assuredly guilty of no violation of any right which Napoleon could claim for himself, nor of any departure from the principles which regulate warfare amongst civilized nations. It must not be forgotten that he had already escaped from Elba, and the result was the battle of Waterloo and the loss of sixty thousand men. And if amongst a neighbouring people, who are the least likely to ac- quiesce in the justice of our treatment of the illustl'ious captive, writers are found to advocate a different theory, and to reproach England for guarding him as a

find (page 274) a note addressed to that officer by General von Qneisenaii, and dated June 29, 1815, in which he says, " I am directed by the Field Marshal (Bliicher) to request your Excellency to conununicate to the Duke of Wellington that it had been his intention to execute Bonaparte on the spot where the Due d'Enghien was shot ; that, out of deference, however, to the Duke's wishes, he will abstain from this measure, but that the Duke must take on himself the responsibility of its non-enforcement."

July, 1815. MODE OF HIS SURRENDER. 13

prisoner instead of entertaining him as a guest, let them remember how Abd el Kadr was for many years kept in close confinement amongst themselves, after he, relying, not on French "generosity," but the solemn promise of a French prince who assured him that he would not be dealt with as a captive, surren- dered himself into the hands of his enemies.^ Napo- leon indeed pretended that he might urge a similar plea. In his protest on board the BeUerophon he said, " I came at the instigation of the captain himself, who declared he had orders from the Government to receive and convey me to England, together with my suite, if agreeable to me. I came forward with confidence to place myself under the protection of the laws of Eng- land." This, however, is distinctly contradicted by Captain Maitland, who in his letter to Mr. Croker, the Secretary of the Admiralty, dated " Basque Roads, July 14th, 1815," after stating that Count Las Cases and Grcneral Lallemand had that day come on board the BeUerophon with a proposal for him to receive Napo- leon Bonaparte, for the purpose of throwing himself on the generosity of the Prince Regent, and that he had acceded to the request, added as follows :^ — " That no misonderstanding might arise I have explicitly and clearly explained to the Count Las Cases that I have no authority whatever for granting terms of any sort ; but all I can do is to convey him and his suite to England, to be received in such manner as His Royal Highness may deem expedient."

So far, therefore, from Captain Maitland instigating

^ The liberation of Abd el Kadr from his long captivity is the most graceful act of the present Emperor of France. His imprisonment throws a deep stain on the government of Louis Philippe.

■ Narrative of the Surrender of Bonaparte, by Captain Maitland, p. 69.

14 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. L

the step taken by Napoleon, or holding out any feJse hopes, he made it known in the most positive manner that he conld guarantee nothing but a safe conveyance of the fugitives across the Channel, to be thereafter dealt with as his Government might think fit.

After much deliberation it was resolved by the English Ministry that Bonaparte should be considered a prisoner of war ; that the island of St. Helena, which then belonged to the East India Company, should be the place of his detention ; that he should be immedi- ately conveyed there in charge of Hear- Admiral Sir (Jeoi^e Cockbum ; and that Sir Hudson Lowe, who then commanded the troops at Marseilles, should be appointed Governor of the island, and have the cus- tody of Napoleon's person.

At the end of July the ex-Emperor was officially informed that he was to be restrained in his personal liberty and sent to St. Helena, and that he might select from those who had accompanied him to Eng- land any three of his officers (except Generals Savary and Lallemand), and his surgeon and twelve servants, to attend him ; but that those persons would not be permitted to quit the island without the sanction of the British Government.

As it was more convenient that H.M.S. the North- umberland, of seventy-four guns, should convey Napo- leon to St. Helena, than that he should proceed in the Bellerophon, that ship was prepared for his reception ; and Sir George Cockbum accordingly hoisted his flag on board of her. The subjoined Instructions, in the form of "Memoranda," for the Admiral's guidance, were transmitted to the Lords of the Admiralty by Earl Bathurst, then Secretary of State for the Depart- ment of War and the Colonies, enclosed in a letter in which his Lordship said, —

July, 1815. IKSTBUCTIONS TO SIR G. COCKBURN. 15

^^In committing so important a trust to British officers, the Prince Eegent is sensible that it is not necessary to impress upon them his anxious desire that no greater measure of severity, with respect to con- finement or restriction, be imposed than what is deemed necessary for the faithM discharge of that duty which the Admiral, as well as the Governor of St. Helena, must ever keep in mind, — ^the perfect security of General Bonaparte's person. Whatever, consistent with this great object, can be allowed in the shape of indulgence. His Royal Highness is confi- dent will be willingly shown to the General ; and he relies on Sir Greorge Cockbum's known zeal and en- ei^ of character that he will not allow himself to be betrayed into any improvident relaxation of his duty."

<< MXMO&ANDA.

" War Depertment, July 30, 1815.

"1. When General Bonaparte shall remove from the BeUerophon into the Northumberland, it will be a fit moment for Admiral Sir George Cockbum to direct an examination of the effects which the General shall have brought with him.

"2. Admiral Sir George Cockbum will allow all articles of furniture, books, and wine, which the Gene- ral may have brought with him, to be transshipped on board the Northumberland.

" 3. Under the head of furniture is to be included his plate, provided it be not to such an amount as to bespeak it to be rather an article of convertible pro- perty than of domestic use.

"4. His money, diamonds, and negotiable bills of every description are to be given up. The Admiral will explain to the General that it is by no means the intention of the British Government to confiscate his

16 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. 1.

property, but simply to take the administration of these effects into their own hands, for the purpose of preventing their being converted by him into an in- strument of escape.

" 5. The examination must be made in the presence of some person appointed by General Bonaparte ; and an inventory of the effects so to be retained must be signed by this person, as well as by the Rear- Admiral, or any one appointed by him to make out the inventory.

" 6. The interest, or the principal (according to the amount of the property), will be applicable to his maintenance ; and the disposition of it, in that respect, left chiefly to his own choice.

"7. He will for that purpose from time to time communicate his wishes to the Admiral, until the new Governor of St. Helena arrives, and to the Governor afterwards ; and, unless the proposition be objection- able, the Admiral or Governor, as the case may be, will give the necessary orders, and the bills will be paid by bills drawn upon His Majesty's Treasury.

" 8. In the event of his death, the disposition of his property will be determined by his will, the contents of which he must be assured will be strictly attended to.

"9. As an attempt may be made to represent part of the property as belonging to persons in his suite, it must be understood that the property of those who go out with him is subject to the same regulation.

" 10. The disposition of the military allotted to guard him must be left to the Gtovernor, the Governor being instructed to attend to the wishes of the Ad- miral in the instances hereafter to be mentioned.

"11. The General must be always attended by an officer appointed by the Admiral or Governor, as the case may be.* If the General be permitted to move

' Count cle Las Casea asserta in his Journal (20-23 Dec. 1815) that it

July, 1815. INSTRUCTIONS TO SIB G. COOKBUBN. 17

beyond the boimdaries where the sentries are placed, the officer should be attended by one orderly at least.

" 12. In the event of ships arriving, so long as they continue in sight the General must be confined within the boundary where the sentries shaU be placed. He must during that interval be prohibited fix)m all inter- course and communication with the inhabitants. They who accompany him to St. Helena must be subject at this period to the same regulations. They are to re- side with him ; and it is left to the discretion of the Admiral in the first instance, and to the new Governor afterwards, to establish such regulations with respect to them at other times as may appear expedient.

" 13. The Admiral will not take on board any indi- vidual belonging to General Bonaparte's suite, for the purpose of conveying him to St. Helena with the General, except with his full consent, after it has been explained to him that he thereby becomes liable to all Ihe regulations to which it may be deemed necessary to subject him for the security of the General's person.

"14. The Gteneral must be given to understand that, in the event of his attempting to escape, he wiU be afterwards subject to close custody ; and they who go out with him must also understand that, if they shall be detected in contriving means for his escape, they will be separated fi-om him, and placed in close custody.

" 15. All letters addressed to him, or his attend- ants, must be first delivered to the Admiral, or to the Governor, as the case may be, who will read them

was one of the orders issued by the English Ministry, that an English ofiBoer should be constantly at Napoleon's table — ^'mesure barbare qui nous e<it priv^ de la douceur de nous trouver en famille ;'* and he adds that the order was not carried into effect only because Bonaparte took his meals in his own chamber. This is simply untrue. Such a measure was never ^ther attempted or intended.

VOL. I. C

18 CAPnVITT OF NAPOLEON. Chap. I.

before they are delivered to the persons to whom they are addressed. All letters written by the General or his attendants must be subject to the same regulation.

*' 16. No letter which has not been transmitted to St. Helena by the Secretary of State should be de- livered to the Greneral, or to those who accompany him, if it be written by any person not resident in the island ; and aU their letters addressed to persons not resident in the island must be sent under cover to the Secretary of State.

" 17. The General must be given clearly to under- stand that the Gk)vemor and -Admiral are strictly instructed to forward to his Majesty's Government any wish or representation which he may think proper to make to the British Government ; and in that par- ticular they are not at liberty to exercise any discre- tion; but the paper on which such application or representation may be written must be left open for their joint inspection, in order that in transmitting it they may be enabled to accompany it with such obser- vations 83 they may think expedient.

*' 18. Until the arrival of the new Governor, the Admiral must be considered as entirely responsible for the security of General Bonaparte's person; and his Majesty's Government entertains no doubt of the dis- position of the actual Governor to concert with the Admiral for this purpose.

" 19. The Admiral is authorized to keep the General on board, or re-embark him, if the security of his person cannot, in the Admiral's opinion, be otherwise obtained.

" 20. On the representation of the Admiral upon his arrival at St. Helena, the Governor will take measures immediately to convey, either to England, or to the Cape, or to the East Indies, according to the circum- stances of the case, such non-commissioned oflBcers and

Aua. 1815. INSTBUCnONS TO SIB Q. COOKBURN. 19

privates in the military corps at St. Helena as the Admiral may deem expedient to relieve from their military duty in the island, by reason of being foreigners, or on account of their general character and disposition.

"21. If there are any foreigners in the island whose residence there appears to the Admiral calculated to be instrumental to General Bonaparte's escape, mea- sures must be taken for their removal.

" 22. The whole coast of the island, and the vessels and boats frequenting it, must be placed under the control of the Admiral. He will regulate the places which boats may frequent ; and on his representation the Governor will station a sufficient guard at those places at which the Admiral may think precaution necessary.

** 23. The Admiral will take the most eflFectual steps to wateh the arrival and departure of every ship, so as to prevent any intercourse with the shore, except such as he may approve.

*'24. An order for preventing, after due notice, foreign ships, and ships belonging to the private trade, from resorting to St. Helena, will be forthwith given.

** 25. If the Greneral should be attacked with any serious indisposition, the Governor and the Admiral will each direct a medical person, in whom they may have confidence, to be in attendance on the General, in addition to his own medical assistance, and direct them severally to report daily on the state of his health.

*' 26. In the event of his death, the Admiral will give orders for his body beifig conveyed to England."

On the 4th of August the Bellerophon sailed from Plymouth Sound to meet the Northumberland, and on the 6th she anchored off the Start. Lord Keith and

c 2

20 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. I.

Sir George Cockbum went on board, and communi- cated to Bonaparte their instructions, part of which were as follows : —

" The Admiral will allow the baggage, wines, and provisions which the (Jeneral may have brought with him to be taken on board the Northumberland. Among the baggage his table-service shall be under- stood as included, unless it be so considerable as to seem rather an article to be converted into ready money than for real use. His money, his diamonds, and his saleable eflfects (consequently bills of exchange also), of whatever kind they may be, must be de- livered up. The Admiral will declare to the General that the British Government by no means intends to confiscate his property, but merely to take upon itself the administration of his effects, to hinder Wm from using them as a means to promote his escape.

" As an attempt might be made to make a part of his property pass for the property of the persons of his suite, it must be signified that the property of his attendants is subject to the same regulations.

" The Admiral is not to take any person on board for St. Helena without the consent of such person, to whom he is previously to explain the necessity of being subjected to all the regulations which it may be thought proper to establish for securing the person of the General. It must be made known to the General, that if he make any attempt to escape he will expose himself to close imprisonment ; and that any of his suite who may be discovered in endeavouring to facili- tate his escape will incur the same punishment. All letters which shall be addressed to him, or to any of his suite, are to be delivered in the first place to the Admiral or the Governor, who is to read them pre-

Aug. 1815. INSTEUCTIONS TO SIR G. COCKBURN. 21

vioosly to transmitting them. The same regulation is to be observed with respect to letters written by the General, or those of his suite.

" The Greneral is to be informed that the (Jovemor and the Admiral have received positive orders to for- ward to his Majesty's Government any request or representation he may think proper to make. Nothing is left to their discretion on this point ; but the paper on which such representations shall be written is to remain open, in order that they may subjoin such observations as they may think expedient."

Captain Maitland also received an order from Lord Keith, that all arms of every description were to be taken from the French, of whatever rank, who were on board the Bellerophon. These arms were to be care- fully packed, and remain in charge of the captain of the Bellerophon, and the captain of the ship to which the French were to be transferred.

This order was not, however, literally executed, for Napoleon was allowed to retain his sword ; and, on their arrival at St. Helena, the swords of the French officers were restored to them.^

' Count Montholon invents a story of Bonaparte's sword having been ' demanded of him on the 7th of August by Lord Keith. His Lordship, he says, *' lui dit^ d*une voiz assonrdie par nne vive Amotion, * L*Angleierre wnu demande votre SpSe.^ L'Empereur, par un mouvement convulsif, posa la main snr cette ^p^e qn'un Anglais osait demander. L'ezpression terrible de son regard fat sa seule r^ponse. Jamais elle n'avait ^t^ pins puissante, pins snrhnmaine. Le vieil Amiral se sentit foudroy^ : sa grande taille s'afiaissa ; sa tete, blanchie par les ann^s, tomba sur sa poitrine comme oelle d'nn oonpable qui sliumilie devant sa oondamnation. L'Empereur garda son ^p^." — RMU de la Captivity de VJEmpereur NapdSon a Satnte- H^HnCy par M. le G^n^ral Montholon : Paris, 1847, torn. i. p. 118. This is pure fiction. The story is contradicted by Count Las Cases in his Jounml, who says, " I asked whether it was possible that they would go so far as to deprive the Emperor of his sword ? The Admiral replied that it ▼ould be respected, but that Napoleon was the only person exempted, as all the rest would be disarmed."— (Ed. Paris, 1824, torn. i. p. 102.)

H

22 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. !•

On the 7th of August Bonaparte was removed to the Northumberland, accompanied by a suite of twenty-five persons ; namely, Count and Countess Ber- trand and their three children ; Count and Countess de Montholon and their child ; Count de Las Cases and his son, a youth of the age of fourteen; Greneral Gourgaud; Marchand, St. Denis (sometimes called Aly), Noverraz, and Santini, vaJets-de-chambre ; the two Archambaults, brothers, grooms ; (lentilini, foot- man ; Cipriani, maitre-d'hStel ; Le Page, cook ; Pier- ron, butler ; Rousseau, steward ; and Josephine, Bernard and his wife, servants of Count Bertrand. As M. Mengeaud, the surgeon who accompanied Na- poleon fipom Rochefort, was unwilling or unable to follow him to St. Helena, Mr. Barry Edward O'Meara, the surgeon of the Bellerophon, was chosen by Bona- parte and permitted by Lord Keith to accompany him in the capacity of medical attendant.

The Northumberland sailed on the 8th of August, with a small squadron consisting of the Havannah frigate and several sloops of war.^ They hove to oflF FunchaJ, in Madeira, for refreshments, and arrived at St. Helena on the 15th of October. In a letter written a few days after they landed by O'Meara, to his friend Mr. Finlaison at the Admiralty (with whom he kept up a secret correspondence, which we shall have occa-

* An account of Napoleon while on board the Northumberland was published by Mr. Warden, surgeon of that vessel, in a work purporting to be ' Letters written on board H. M. S. Northumberland and at St. Helena.' There is little doubt, however, that this title was a misnomer, and that the letters were in reality concocted in England afterwards from notes perhaps taken previously. This is proved by the internal evidence of various dis- crepancies and mistakes which could not have occurred if the letters had been written at the dates they profess to bear. They were ably criticised in the 'Quarterly Review,' No. XXXI., p. 208, and No. XXXII., p. 486. We shall have occasion again to advert to Mr. Warden's book in the course of the narrative.

Oct, 1815. THE VOYAGE TO ST. HELENA. 23

sion to consider more fully hereafter), he gives a description of the exiles on board the Northumberland, which stands in remarkable contrast to the style of his printed work, and the tone in which he there speaks of the French ladies at Longwood. Nothing but the necessity there is for exhibiting this writer in his true colours, and showing what were his real opinions, could induce me to publish such remarks. But it must not for a moment be imagined that what O'Meara says in disparagement of others is to be believed because he asserts it. Henceforward we may hope that the character of no one will be affected by his statements. In the letter referred to he says, —

" During the passage the ladies were either ill the whole time or fancied themselves to be so, in either of which cases it was necessary to give them medicine, in the choice of which it was extremely diflBcult to meet their tastes or humours, or their ever unceasing ca- price ; what was most extraordinary, they never com- plained of loss of appetite. They generally eat of every dish in a profusely supplied table of different meats twice every day, besides occasional tiffins, bowls of soup, &c. They mostly hate each other, and I am the depository of their complaints, especially Madame Bertrand's, who is like a tigress deprived of her young whenever she perceives me doing any service for Madame Montholon. The latter, to tell the truth, is not so whimsical nor subject to so many fits of rage as the other. Bonaparte was nearly the entire of the time in perfect health. . . . During the passage Na- poleon almost invariably did not appear out in the after-cabin before 12 ; breakfasted either in bed or in his own cabin about 11; dined with the Admiral about 5 ; stayed about half an hour at dinner, then

24 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. I.

left the table and proceeded to the quarter-deck, where he generally spent a couple of hours either in walking or else leaning against the breach of one of the quarter- deck guns, talking to De Las Cases. He generally spoke a few words to every officer who could under- stand him; and, according to his usual custom, was very inquisitive relative to various subjects. His suite, until the day before he landed (three days after our arrival), invariably kept their hats off while speaking to him, and then by his directions remained covered. He professes his intention (I am informed) to drop the name of Bonaparte, and to assume that of a Colonel he was very partial to, and who was killed in Italy. He is to proceed in a few days to Long- wood, the present seat of the Lieutenant-Governor, where there is a plain of above a mile and a half in length, with trees (a great rarity here) on it. He is to have a captain constantly in the house with him, and is also to be accompanied by one whenever he goes out : none of his staff are to go out unless accompa- nied by an English officer or soldier. I had a long conversation with him the day before yesterday. ■Amongst other remarks he observed, *Why, your Grovemment have not taken the most economical me- thod of providing for me ; they send me to a place where every necessary of life is four times as dear as in any other part of the globe ; and, not content with that, they send a regiment here, to a place where there are already four times as many inhabitants as it can furnish subsistence to,^ and where there are a super-

* Upon this passage Sir Hudson Lowe has observed, '* There is truth in this remark, yet the Governor is constantly abused both as to the quality and quantity of the provisions, as if he oould have always had access to a regularly supplied European market. The difficulties in this respect are little imderstood in Europe."

Oct. 1815. HIS OPINIOK OP THE ISLAND. 25

abundance of troops also. This is the way,' continued he, * that you have contracted your national debt ; not by the actual necessary expenses of the war, but by unnecessary expenses of colonies. This island costs, or will cost, two millions a year, which is so much money thrown in the sea. Your East India Com- pany,* said he, * if their affairs were narrowly scruti- nized, would be found to lose instead of gaining, and in a few years must become bankrupt. Your manu- factories, in consequence of the deamess of necessaries in England, will be undersold by those of France and Grermany, and the manufacturers will be mined.' He is gready displeased with the island : he says * there is nothing good in it but air^ "^

' '* It is here admitted that the air was goody and where the air is good the dimate cannot he had/* — Note by Sir Hudson Lowe. Beferring to this passage Sir Hudson Lowe ohserves, — '* On this, and indeed on all other speci^ed suhjects of complaint, I may quote a suppressed passage from the Journal of Count Las Oases, which told too much to he published — ' Les details de 8ie, ffSlhie sent peu de chose ; o'est d^t Atbe qui est la grande affaire.' "

Count Las Cases tells us in his Journal that Bonaparte remarked to him on the Ist of February, 1816, <' After all, as a place of exile, perhaps St. Helena was the hc»t. (Aprte tout, exil pour exil, 8te. H^^e ^tait peut-dtiB la meilleure place.) In high latitudes we should have suffered greatly from cold, and in any other island of the tropics we should have expired miserably under the scorching rays of the sun. This rock is wild and barren, no doubt ; the climate is monstrous and unwholesome ; but the temperature, it must be confessed, is mild (doucey*

26 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. !!•

CHAPTER 11.

SAINT HELENA — THE 'BRIARS — LONQWOOD — OORRESPONDENCB OF SIR GEORGE CX)CKBURN WITH COUNTS MONTHOLON AND BERTRAND — O'MEARA.

What were the feelings of the imperial captive when he first gazed upon that lonely rock of the ocean which was henceforth to be his island prison ? Al- though he once said of himself that he had a soul of marble,^ he was not cast in the mould of the fallen AjTchangel, who could exclaim in all the pride of un- conquerable self-reliance,

" What matter where, if I be still the same ? "

The mind of Napoleon was dependent for happiness on the accidents of external fortune. He had an organization which was sensitive in the extreme. It has been truly said that exalted genius has generally in its composition something of a feminine as distinguished from an effeminate nature, and this is perhaps the reason why it is so often susceptible of annoyances and disgusts which a coarser and rougher temperament does not feel. We have read an anec- dote of Napoleon which tells us that, when once in the presence of his troops he tasted some of the soldiers' soup, he had the greatest diflBculty in swallowing it because he detected a hair in the spoon. He mastered, however, although he could not wholly conceal his repugnance. The sight of St. Helena must have smitten the heart of such a man with dismay. Its appearance from the sea is gloomy and forbidding.

» Voice from St. Helena, ii. 391.

Oct. 1815. SCENERY OF ST. HELENA. 27

Masses of volcanic rock with sharp and jagged peaks tower up round the coast and form an iron girdle which seems to bar all access to the interior. And the few points where a landing can be effected were then bristling with cannon, so as to render the aspect still more formidable.

The whole island bears evidence of having been formed by the tremendous agency of fire, but so gigantic are the strata of which it is composed, and so disproportioned to its size, that some have thought it the relic and wreck of a vast submerged continent. Its seared and barren sides, without foliage or ver- dure, present an appearance of dreary desolation. No delicious scenery, like that of Funchal in Madeira, allures the mariner to stop on his voyage, and the exigency arising from the want of water or provisions alone induces him to visit the lonely rock. But even here nature has not left herself without witness that she possesses softer charms. There are few places in the earth where we can travel from Dan to Beer- sheba and say with truth that all is barren. In the narrow valleys that radiate from the great basaltic ridge which forms the back-bone of the island and wind themselves between the hills towards the coast she has scattered loveliness with a lavish hand. Ye- getation there flourishes, and the eye is gratified and refreshed with a variety of foliage and the verdure of grassy slopes. "That the outwardly wild and shape- less mass of rock which St. Helena seems upon its being ' approached," says an accurate observer, "should con- tain the alternation of hiU and dale, and the delightful scenes of luxuriant and endless verdure, which in the interior everywhere meet the eye, has been the won- der of all who have ever beheld them."^

* Scale's * GeognoBy of St. Helena.'

28 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. H,

But on emerging firom the ravines to those parts of the island where there is any table-land, a different kind of scenery appears. Here there is little wood, except that of tiie gum-tree, which affords scanty shade, and on every side frown masses of dark rock, the summits of which are clothed with the cabbage- tree and a gigantic species of fern.

« Each purple peak, each flinty spire, Is bathed in floods of liying fire ; But not a setting beam can glow Within the dark ravines below."

The plains in the upland, however, which exist only at Deadwood and Longwood, are by no means barren. They are covered at various depths with a shaggy lava of a brown and reddish hue, with a steel tarnish of amorphous scoriae, parts of which soil yield com and pasture in abundance. And the climate here is more healthy than in the valleys. The heat of the sun is tempered by a refreshing breeze, which, wafted from the southern ocean, envelops the more elevated parts of the island in a shroud of mist. With respect to the climate, Lieutenant-Colonel Jack- son, in a letter to the author, gives the following account of his experience of it during several years : — "Lying within the influence of the south-east trade- wind, which is usually a strong breeze between the Cape and St. Helena, the tropical heat is moderated thereby to a delightful temperature, and perhaps there is no finer climate to be found than in certain parts of St. Helena. In the town I rarely saw the thermo- meter above 80°, while the general height may have been about 75°. But I write from memory, having lost my register of the temperature. Between Long- wood and James Town there is a diflference of 8° or 10°. A fire is rarely necessary, unless perhaps as a corrective of the dampness produced by fog, to which

Oct. 1815. HEALTHINESS OF ST. HELENA. 29

the elevated portions of the island are occasionally liable. I believe the average duration of life at St. Helena to be much as in England."

And Mr. Henry, who was stationed there as assistant- surgeon during the time of Napoleon's residence at Longwood, says,^ —

"For a tropical climate, only fifteen degrees from the line,^ St. Helena is certainly a healthy island, if not the most healthy of this description in the world. During one period of twelve months, we did not lose one man by disease out of five hundred of the 66th quartered at Deadwood. In 1817, 18, and 19, Fah- renheit's thermometer kept at the hospital there ranged from fifty-five to seventy degrees, with the exception of two calm days when it rose to eighty. It was about twelve degrees higher in the valleys and in James Town on an average ; but from the situation of the latter, and the peculiar radiation of heat to which it was exposed, the temperature was sometimes upwards of ninety. The great source of health and comparative coolness in St. Helena is the south-east trade-wind, coming from an immense extent of the southern ocean, which winnows the rock, and wafts over it every morning a cloudy awning that mitigates the strong sun. This is not without concomitant humidity in the highlands for half the year, but the inconvenience is as nothing compared with the com- fort, fertility, and salubrity which the clouds bestow.

" Notwithstanding the assertions of Napoleon's ad- herents, who had an interest in painting the place in as dark colours as they could, I must maintain that, correctly speaking, we had no endemic disease in the

' Events of a Military Life, vol. ii. p. 45.

• It would be more accurate to say sixteen degrees, St. Helena is situated 15** 55' south latitude.

30 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. II.

island. Human life, certainly, did not extend to the aame length as in cooler regions, though some organs appeared to be privileged there ; diseases of the lungs, for instance, being very rare. It has been stated that there are no old people in the island, but this is cer- tainly a mistake, though the proportion may appear small to an English eye. I believe it is as large as in Spain and the south of Italy ; and I have seen some blacks of eighty, and whites approaching ninety. The upper parts of St. Helena, including the residence of Bonaparte, are decidedly the most healthy, and we often moved our regimental convalescents from James Town to Deadwood for cooler and better air. The clouds moved so steadily and regularly with the trade-wind, that there appeared to be no time for atmospherical accumulations of electricity, and we never had any thunder or lightning. No instance of hydrophobia in man or any inferior animal had ever been known in St. Helena."

Napoleon did not land at James Town until the evening of the 17th of October, when he took up his abode for one night in the town, at the house of Mr. Porteous, which had been engaged for him by the Ad- miral, but the next day he removed to the Briars, a country house about a mile and a half from James Town, belonging to Mr. Balcombe, who afterwards became purveyor to the establishment at Longwood.

On the 17th two proclamations were issued by Colonel Wilkes, the acting Governor of the island.

One of these warned "all the inhabitants or other persons on this island from aiding or abetting here- after, in any way whatever, the escape of the said General Napoleon Bonaparte, or that of any of the French persons who have arrived here with him, and

Oct. 1816. COU WILKES'S PROCLAMATIONS. 31

interdicted most pointedly the holding of any commu- nication or correspondence with him or them, except- ing only such as may regularly be authorized by the Governor, or Rear- Admiral Sir George Cockbum, in whose immediate charge the said General Bonaparte and his attendants are particularly placed." The other was as follows : —

" Pboclamation.

" October 17, 1816.

"Whereas, during the detention at St. Helena <rf General Napoleon Bonaparte, and the French persons attending him, it appears essentially necessary to adopt some additional precautions on the island, and particularly by night : This is therefore to give notice to aU the inhabitants and other persons of every de- scription, that after this date nobody whatever will be permitted to pass in any part of the island (excepting within the immediate precincts of the town), between the hours of nine at night and dayU^t in the morning, without having the parole of the night, the sentries and patrols having orders henceforth to secure and hold as prisoners until morning all persons they may find between the said periods not possessing the pa- role ; and the oflScers of the different guards, &c., are to cause all persons so taken up to be sent, prior to being released the next morning, to the Governor, with a statement of the particular circumstances under which they were apprehended, that he may, if he judge necessary, make such further investigation into the case, or take such further steps respecting it, as to him may appear advisable. It is distinctly to be imderstood by the inhabitants that this ordinance is in no respect intended to interfere with the customary intercourse of hospitality, and that every proper fa- cility will be given to any respectable inhabitant who

32 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. H.

may intend to return home at a later hour than nine o'clock, by application to the field-officer of the day if going from town, or to the commissioned officer com- manding any outpost in the country; but a written report of all persons to whom the parole may thus have been granted in the country must be made to the field- officer of the day on the ensuing morning. Patrols from all the outposts are to be sent at uncertain hours of the night, to be determined by the field-officer of the day, for the purpose of enforcing this regulation."

Another proclamation on the same day declared that the whole coast of the island and all vessels and boats belonging to it were placed under the immediate con- trol of Sir George Cockbum, and all owners of boats were commanded to make an exact return, specifying the description and use to which they were applied.

On the 22nd of October Sir George Cockburn sent H.M.S. Redpole to England, and addressed an inte- resting report of his proceedings to Mr. Oroker, Secre- tary to the Admiralty. In his despatch he said, —

" On the day of my arrival I lost no time in con- sulting fully with Gt)vemor Wilkes upon the subject of the important duties with which I am charged ; and the next day, having visited the diflferent houses and estates throughout the island, and the Governor, as well as the Members of the Council, and every other person I have consulted here, most fully concurring with me in considering Longwood not only the best, but the only place on the island calculated to answer for the future residence of General Bonaparte, I have not hesitated in fixing upon it for the purpose accord- ingly. Longwood is detached from the general in- habited parts of the island, therefore none of the inhabitants have occasion, or are at all likely, to be

Oct. 1815. SIB G. COCKBURN'S FIRST DESPATCH. 33

met with passing in its neighbourhood, excepting those who have business with the General or the estate : it is the most distant from the parts of the coast of the island always accessible to boats, some of which spots, owing to the present inadequacy of their defence the Governor considers it of importance to keep from the view of General Bonaparte and his military followers; and at Longwood an extent of level ground (easily to be secured by sentries) pre- sents itself^ perfectly adapted for horse exercise, car- riage exercise, or for pleasant walking, which is not to be met with in all the other parts of the island. The houde is certainly small ; but it is, I think, equal in size and convenience to any of the others I have seen on the island (out of the town), excepting only the Governor's (Plantation House) ; and I trust the carpenters of the Northumberland, with the assistance of flie workmen the Governor has kindly oflfered me, will in a little time be able to make such additions to the house as will render it, if not as good a one as might be wished, yet at least as commodious as neces* sary; and whenever the artificers and frames, Ac, my Lord Mulgrave promised to send after me, arrive, we shall be enabled further to improve it to any extent required.

" I have found the premises of Longwood in pos- session of the Lieutenant-Governor, but this oflScer, also most fully concurring in the advantages it offers for the residence of General Bonaparte, has most readily consented to change as quickly as possible into another house, and has already commenced mov- ing his effects, Ac, accordingly. I have therefore reason to hope I shall be enabled to get the General and his party into it in the course of next week. In the mean time, as, after being so long confined on

VOL. I. D

34 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. II.

board of ship, the Gkneral showed much anxiety to be permitted to land, which might also be considered necessary for his health, and the Governor not show- ing any objections to it, I have hired for the moment a furnished house in the town by the week, in which are now General Bertrand and all the other attendants ; the General himself having, at his own request, re- moved the day after his landing to a small house a little way out of the town, in which there is only one spare room for himself.

" I now beg to draw their Lordships' attention to the subject of the expenses to be incurred for the maintenance of General Bonaparte and his followers on this island, upon which point, my instructions not being very detailed, I will venture to adopt such measures as appear to me most advisable under the existing circumstances, until I can receive the further pleasure of His Majesty's Government. I find that neither General Bonaparte nor any of his followers have brought him an article of furniture excepting a small service of plate, and another of Sevres china ; linen, and everything else, therefore, for the establish- ment of Longwood, must be purchased for them ; and as they have not brought any money with them, and the sum I took from them on board the Bellerophon and transmitted to the Treasury proved so small that it becomes out of the question looking to it for cover- ing the expenses for establishing and maintaining here the General and his suite, agreeably to what I consider the intention of His Majesty's (Government on this head — viz. * that, as far as it may prove practicable, such comforts and establishment as are usually enjoyed by officers bearing the rank of full General should be allowed to General Bonaparte, and a table of eight covers kept for him, with everything else in a similar

Oct. 1815. SIK G. COCKBURN^ FIBST DESPATCH. 35

ratio ' — ^I propose to draw, from time to time, from the commissary such sums as may be necessary for the furnishing and keeping up accordingly, or as near as conveniently may be, an establishment of this nar ture for the General and his suite ; and the better to enable me to effect this at the cheapest rate, and to avoid tiie imposition I might be liable to as a stranger, I have engaged a Mr. Balcombe, a respectable in- habitant, strongly recommended to me by Colonel Beatson before I quitted England, and by the Go- vernor since my arrival, as most conversant and eflBcient in such matters, to purvey for me, and gene- rally to assist me in procuring the several things it becomes necessary for me to purchase upon the island. . . . And it is necessary I should add, whilst on this subject, that the Count de Bertrand has already ap- plied to me to know what allowances himself and the other attendants of Bonaparte may look for, indepen- dent of their maintenance and lodging. I avoided giving a direct answer to him, on the plea of not having precise instructions on the point ; but it does not appear that any of these people have private for- tunes of their own, by means of which they might be supplied ; and as themselves smd their families will be constantly wanting clothes, &c., it becomes a subject on which I beg to request I may be famished with directions. General Bonaparte has since his arrival also applied to me for a carriage, on the plea of its being often the only exercise he can take; and as fortunately Governor Wilkes happens to have one which he will spare me for this purpose, I shall not hesitate in purchasing it; and the General having also applied to me to cause him to be furnished with horses, I propose to send to the Cape for some for him, such indulgence appearing to me to come decidedly

D 2

36 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. II.

within the idea I have of the comforts and establish- ment intended to be allowed him.

"I am sorry to have to add that, since General Bonaparte has landed here, he has appeared less re- signed to his fate, and has expressed himself more dissatisfied with the lot decreed him, than he did before ; this however I merely attribute to the first effects of the general sterile appearance of this island around where he now resides, and the little prospect it yields himself and followers of meeting with any of those amusements and enjoyments they have been accustomed to. I am therefore the more anxious to get them into Longwood, where the appearance of the country is so much better ; and when I have procured for them the carriage, horses, &c., before mentioned, I am not without hopes that this discontented turn may again wear off; and their Lordships will, I trust, very readily believe that nothing shall ever be wanting on my part to render the General's detention here as little afflictive and irksome to him as possible, so long as the paramount object of his personal security

be not compromised

" I have considered it incumbent on me to send back to England, also in the Redpole, a French ser- vant who was smuggled on board the Northumberland, in addition to the twelve domestics allowed to General Bonaparte, in the hurry of the transshipment from the Bellerophon, though I had previously most pointedly refused to allow of his going. I have therefore not permitted him to set his foot ashore here, and I have directed Captain Denman to be careful to secure him when he arrives in England, until their Lordships*

pleasure respecting him shall be known

" I have now only to add, for their Lordships' con- sideration, that my present idea is, with a view to

Nov. 1815. COUNT BERTRAND'S PROTEST. 37

I)erfect the security of this island, two vessels of war should be always kept at anchor here, one where the Northumberland now is, and one as fer to the south- ward as she can get shelter; and two brigs in addition to those already sent should also be kept cruizing in the offing, one in the north and the other in the south ; to enable me to effect which, giving the necessary relief and to supply contingencies, I should require three more vessels of war under my command than are now upon the station, and I must submit to their Lordships the propriety of sending another post- captain to continue on it, to enable me to maintain the necessary discipline by courts-martial, in the event of the same becoming necessary."

On the 5th of November Count Bertrand addressed the following letter and " note " ^ to Sir George Cock- bum, protesting against the whole proceedings of the English Government towards Napoleon and his suite, and complaining of the regulations to which they were subjected. It should be observed that, although every possible effort was made to render Longwood fit for their reception, it was not ready until the 9 th of Pecember : —

** Monsieur TAmiral, "St. Helena, 5ih November, 1815.

" As you are charged with everything concerning us, I have the honour to address to you a Note of the way in which the service about the person of the Em- peror has hitherto been performed. I wiU occasionally write to you on what regards us. — Pray accept, &c.

" The Grand Mar£ghal Comte Bertrand."

* Thxx)aghoat the present work translations are generally given of letters, documents, and expressions in a foreign language, but, wherever it can bo at all important to know the exact words used in the original, they are subjoined.

38 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. II.

"NOTB.

" The Emperor embarked on board the Bellerophon in the roads oflf the He d'Aix on the 15th of July ; he remained on board without landing till the 7th of August, when he was put on board the Northumber^ land; she sailed immediately for St. Helena, and anchored in the roadstead on the 15th of October at nine in the morning, and the Emperor remained on board during the 15th and 16th. On the 17th, at eight in the evening, after i passage of ninety-five days, the Emperor, accompanied by Admiral Sir George Gockburn and the Grand Mar^chal, landed, and repaired to a furnished house, where he occupied one room, the rest of the house being occupied by the officers and other persons of his suite. The next day, the 18th, at six in the morning, he went on horseback with the Admiral and Grand Marfechal to look at Longwood, where he breakfasted with the Lieutenant- Governor. On his return he stopped at a place two miles from the town, and situated at the extremity of the valley, preferring to live here in a room which the Admiral had prepared, rather than in the house in town, which had neither court nor garden in which he could walk. The Emperor is still in the same lodging, where he is very uncomfortable, the pavilion having but one room, in which he is obliged to sleep, eat, work, and remain all day. The Comte de Las Cases and his son occupy a small chamber above. After so long a confinement on board ship it would have been very desirable if the Emperor could have had a bath ; but this was not possible, the place oflfering no conve- nience of any kind. It is necessary that the Emperor should be able to ride on horseback ; for this purpose a few saddle-horses are requisite, which would be attended to by his own people — one for himself, one

Nov. 1816. THE ADMIRAL»S ANSWER. 39

for an officer of his suite, and a third for his servant. After having been for three weeks on board the Bel- lerophon with onrarms, and surrounded by the respect due to the Emperor and to our rank, we were dis- srmeAj in violation of all justice, and even contrary to the usages of war in the case of general officers. The Admiral has just returned onr swords to us, but on the condition of our not using them, as we are always to consider ourselves prisoners of war. Indeed we cannot communicate with the pavilion occupied by the Emperor without being accompanied by a Serjeant ; and the Emperor himself was at first surrounded by sentries and officers on duty. The sentries have since been withdrawn. It is greatly to be desired that the authorities would so conduct themselves towards the Emperor as to banish from his mind all recollection of the painful position in which he is placed ; I do not hesitate to say it is such as barbarians even would be touched by and have consideration for. It cannot be feared that any escape can be eflfected from this rock, almost everywhere inaccessible. Why can they not, if it be deemed necessary, increase the guard on the coast, and allow us to ramble over the island without restraint ? It were also much to be wished that we might be lodged near the Emperor, to bear him company.

"The Grand MARScffAL Comte Bertrand/*

To this Sir George Cockburn answered, —

** Northumberland, St. Helena Roads, " Sir, " November 6, 1815.

" I have the honour to acknowledge the receipt of your letter and note of yesterday's date, by which you oblige me officially to explain to you that I have no cognizance of any Emperor being actually upon this

40 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. U.

island, or of any person possessing such dignity haying (as stated by you) come hither with me in the North- umberland. With regard to yourself and the other oflScers of distinction who have accompanied you here, it has been, and will continue to be, my most anxious study to render your situations as little irksome and disagreeable as possible under the existing circum- stances ; and I can only further assure you that I very sincerely lament to find my endeavours on this head seem hitherto to have proved unsuccessful. I do myself also the honour of stating to you, in reply to a part of your note, that it is incompatible witli my instructions to permit of your passing beyond the established line of sentries without your being accom- panied by an English officer or non-commissioned officer. I seize this opportunity to beg of you to accept the assurances, &c.*

"G. Cockburn/'

Sir Gteorge Cockbum transmitted this correspond- ence to England on the 11th of the same month, and wrote to Earl Bathurst : —

" I beg permission to remark to your Lordship upon this curious note, that, although the tenor of it pre- vented my entering at all into the merits of M. de Bertrand's statement, yet General Bonaparte (if by the term * Emperor ' he meant to designate that per- son) inhabits his present temporary residence wholly and solely in compliance with his own urgent and pointed request after looking at it; and the only English officer stationed there is the one in attend- ance upon the General, agreeably to my instructions on that head.

" I will only detain your Lordship, however, whilst

» See*Recit8,»i. 176.

NoY. 1815. HIS RIGHT TO THE IMPERUL TITLE. 41

I add, that since my amval in this island I have not ceased in my endeavours to render these people as comfortable as their situations and the existing cir- cumstances would admit of; but, I am. sorry to say, I find their requests and complaints (particularly those of M. de Bertrand) but increase with every fiivour and attention shown them."

There is, it must be confessed, some aflfectation in this letter; and we can only smile at Sir George Cockburn's doubt as to who was meant by "the Emperor" at St. Helena. Upon the question of the imperial title, it is, I think, difficult to refute the arguments used by Napoleon in favour of his right to be styled Emperor. We^ indeed, had not re- cognised that title when he was on the throne of France, but the reason was that we had been at war with him from a period prior to his assump- tion of the imperial crown; and no opportunity had occurred for the interchange of courtesies as between friendly powers. But he was not the less Emperor of France, by a solemn act of coronation, with the assent and amidst the acclamations of the nation ; nor can we for a moment doubt that if, at any time between his ceasing to be First Consul and his invasion of Spain, he had been willing to make peace upon fair and equitable terms, England would have treated with him in his character of Emperor. Indeed she did so at Chatillon in 1814 ; and if Napoleon had only then been true to himself, and not been dazzled by a temporary success over the troops of Blucher into a belief that he could arrest the tide of invasion which was rolling over France, he might have kept possession of the imperial throne, with the full assent of England, provided that he was content with the ancient limits of the monarchy.

42 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. II.

It seemed paerile in us to ignore a title by which he will be known in history as certainly as Augustus or Charlemagne. It cannot be urged that to recognise Napoleon as Emperor would have been to abandon the cause of the Bourbons, for we had previously concluded the treaty of Amiens with him as the de facto ruler of France ; and we had no right to im- pose either a king or a form of government upon that country. A better reason than the almost technical one, that we had not acknowledged him as Emperor in the height of his power, and ought not therefore to do so in his fall, may be found in the danger there might be of keeping alive pretensions which Napoleon had formally renounced. His partisans might be less ready to abandon the cause of their former master while he retained the imperial style, and was present to their minds still as the Em- peror, acknowledged as such by the powers of Eu- rope. But there would have been no difficulty in calling him ea?-Emperor, which would have suffi- ciently expressed the history of the past and the fact of the present. It would have gratified his feel- ings, and done much to smooth the difficulties which occurred at St. Helena. Or the English Ministry might have promptly acceded to his own expressed wish to assume an incognito, and take the name of Baron Duroc or Colonel Meudon, which he himself more than once proposed ; but Lord Bathurst, as will be seen, threw cold water on the suggestion when it was communicated to him by Sir Hudson Lowe.

At all events, I think we chose for him the worst title that could have been selected. We cannot wonder that he who had entered every capital on the continent of Europe as a conqueror, — who had par- titioned kingdoms and dictated laws to nations, — who

Nov. 1815. THE IMPERIAL TITLE. 43

had created Marshals of world-wide renown, and had been for seven years seated on the throne of France, — should have felt it as an insult to be told that he was henceforth to be known only as Greneral Bonaparte. A philosopher might indeed have cared little for the name of former sovereignty when its power and re- ality were gone for ever; but Napoleon Bonaparte was not a philosopher. He had played for the prize of worldly ambition and won a greater stake than had ever fedlen to the lot of man. He was not indifferent to titular distinction, and did not affect to despise the insignia of power. " He persisted," says Lamartine,^ "with an affectation which his flatterers consider heroic, but which history will judge as puerile, because it is a misconception of his fortune, in exacting the titles of Emperor and Majesty, which England, never having acknowledged the Empire, was not oflScially bound to give him. He appealed to heaven and earth against this breach of etiquette. He dictated notes on this trifle as he would have done on the conquest or the loss of Europe." It was, throughout the whole period of his captivity at St. Helena, a constant sub- ject of irritation and dispute ; and, as he himself said, one half of the disgusts he there experienced originated in that source. But it would, I think, have been more magnanimous in England to have humoured in this point the wish of fallen greatness ; and no real danger need have been apprehended, although perhaps some little inconvenience might be felt.

Sir George Cockbum wrote to the Admiralty, and suggested that ships coining to St. Helena should call at Bordeaux for claret and other French wines, " as General Bonaparte and his followers (the ladies and

* Histoixe de la Restauration.

44 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. II.

children as well as the gentlemen) invariably drink wine at breakfast, dinner, and supper ;" and to give some idea of the average expense of this, he enclosed a statement of the wines which had been consumed on the passage out, in addition to some casks of inferior description for the servants. The whole amounted to more than a hundred dozen of wines of various kinds. Instructions of the most rigorous nature were given to the officers in command of the various posts and guards, especially those towards the sea, to prevent improper or unauthorised communication with any part of the island ; and in addition, an orderly officer^ was placed in constant attendance upon Bonaparte, whose duties are best shown by his instructions : —

"The officer charged with this duty is not to absent himself from the premises where the General may be staying, more than two hours at a time, with- out having obtained the sanction of the Admiral or Commandant. He is to make a point of seeing or of obtaining satisfactory information of the General being on the spot, at least twice in the twenty-four hours : by * satisfeictory information' is meant such as Dr. O'Meara, or other person of responsibility, reporting having seen him in his own room, confined by sickness or otherwise. Copies of the proclamations which have been, or which may be, issued here with reference to, and in consequence of, the General's being detained upon this island, should be delivered to the officer charged with this duty ; and he will be expected to see them attended to and complied with as far as the same may depend upon him, and to be very careful to inform the Admiral whenever he has cognizance of

^ The first orderly officer was Captain Thomas Poppleton, of the 53rd re;;iment.

Kov. 1815. INSTRUCTIONS FOR ORDERLY OFFICER. 45

their being in the slightest degree infringed ; and he is to endeavour (as far as may be practicable without attracting tiie Generars notice) to prevent the slaves upon the island from approaching, so as to render their being talked to by him likely. Whenever the (Jeneral rides or walks beyond the boundaries where the sentries are placed, he is to be invariably attended by the officer; and should the General during such rides or walks approach the coast, or any of the forti- fied parts of the island, the officer is respectfully to request of him to turn in some other direction, ac- quainting him (if requisite) with the reason. After the arrival of the dragoons written for from the Cape, the officer is, during such excursions, to be always attended by one orderly at least ; and the officer on this duty is every day to despatch one of them to the Admiral at eight o'clock in the morning, and at sunset in the evening, with a written report, signed by the said officer, stating the hour the General was last seen by him, or that he received satisfactory information of his being on the spot, and whether everything is going on well with regard to the General and his French attendants, or otherwise, as the case may be. He is likewise to be particular in informing the Admiral whenever he observes symptoms of packing parcels or trunks, or in short any extraordinary movements amongst any of the Frenchmen which may in the least tend to awaken a suspicion respecting tiiem ; and he is always to keep a dragoon in attendance ready to send off at a moment's warning between the above sffecified hours, should circumstances arise which he Daay judge it advisable to communicate speedily to the Admiral. He is to take care that the General and (after they are established at Longwood) all his at- tendants are within the house by nine o'clock (a signal

48 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. II.

rough stone wall. The space, however, within which Napoleon might ride or walk unattended by an officer, and in complete seclusion, was triangular in form, and embraced a circuit of twelve miles. Within it was situated nearly all the tolerably level ground in the island, and both Longwood and Deadwood adjoining, where the British troops were encamped, were nearly flat and well covered with turf. On the latter ground was formed an excellent raccrcourse, a mile and a half in length, of which one mile was in a straight line. The plateau on which Longwood stands is flanked on all sides by deep and precipitous ravines which form walls of rock inaccessible to the foot of man, and the road leading to it from James Town runs along the top of a narrow ridge, on one side of which lies a tremendous hollow, known by the name of the Devil's Punch Bowl.

The house at Longwood had been originally in- tended as a country residence for the Governor of the island, and was at first merely a small dwelling of one story. It was added to for the reception of Bona- parte and his suite, and a tolerably correct but not flattering idea of it may be gathered from the follow- ing description given by O'Meara in his book : —

" Longwood is situated on a plain formed on the summit of a mountain, about eighteen hundred feet above the level of the sea ; and, including Deadwood, comprises fourteen or fifteen hundred acres of land, a great part of which is planted with an indigenous tree called gumwood. Its appearance is sombre and unpro- mising Unfortunately the house only consisted

of five rooms on a ground floor, which had been built one after the other, according to the wants of the family, and without any regard to either order or

Dm. 1815. DESCRIPTION OP LONQWOOD HOUSE. 49

conyenience, and were totally inadequate for the ac- commodation of himself and his suite. Several addi- tions were consequently necessary By means

of incessant labour Longwood House was enlarged so as to admit, on the 9 th of December, Napoleon and part of his household, Count and Countess Montholon and children, Count and young Las Cases. Napoleon himself had a small narrow bedroom on the ground- floor, a writing-room of the same dimensions, and a sort of small antechamber, in which a bath was put up. The writing-room opened into a dark and low apartment, which was converted into a dining-room. The opposite wing consisted of a bedroom, lai^er than that of Napoleon, which, with an antechamber and closet, formed the accommodation for Count and Coun- tess Montholon and son. From the dining-room a door led to a drawing-room, about eighteen feet by fifteen. In prolongation of this, one longer, much higher, and more airy, was built of wood by Sir George Cockburn, with three windows on each side, and a verandah lead- ing to the garden. This, although it laboured under the inconvenience of becoming intolerably hot towards the evening, whenever the sun shone forth in tropical splendour, by the rays penetrating the wood of which it was composed, was the only good room in the building. Las Cases had a room next the kitchen,* which had formerly been occupied by some of Colonel Skelton's servants, through the ceiling of which an opening was cut so as to admit a very narrow stair, which led to a sort of cockloft above, where his son

' '* Some time afterwards an apartment was built for the Count and his son at the back of the house, which was subsequently divided into a bed and sitting room, with one for their servant. They were so small that there was not room for a chair between the bedsteads of the father and son, and 80 low that the ceiling could be touched by a person standing on the floor ."— Kt/icfjp. 16, note.

VOL. I. E

50 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. U.

reposed. The garrets over the old building were floored and converted into apartments for Marchand, Cipriani, St. Denis, Josephine, &c. From the sloping structure of the roof, it was impossible to stand upright in those garrets, unless in the centre ; and the sun, penetrating through the slating, rendered them occa- sionally insupportably hot. Additional rooms were constructing for them, and for General Gourgaud, the orderly officer, and myself, who, in the mean time,

were accommodated with tents Count and

Countess Bertrand and family were lodged in a little house at Hutt's Gate, about a mile from Longwood, which, though uncomfortable, was nevertheless hired at their own request, and was the only one which could be procured at a moderate rate in the neighboujv hood, as it was found impossible to accommodate them at Longwood until a new house, the foundation of which was immediately laid down by Sir George

Cockbum, could be finished A space of about

twelve miles in circumference was allotted to Napo- leon, within which he might ride or walk, without being accompanied by a British olBficer. Within this space was placed the camp of the 53rd, at Deadwood, about a mile from Longwood house, and another at Hutt's Gate, opposite Bertrand's, close to whose door

there was an oflficer's guard A subaltern's

guard was posted at the entrance of Longwood, about six hundred paces from the house, and a cordon of sentinels and piquets were placed round the limits* At nine o'clock the sentinels were drawn in, and stationed in communication with each other, sur- rounding the house in such positions that no person could come in or go out without being seen and scrutinized by them. At the entrance of the house double sentinels were placed, and patrols were con-

Dk. 1816. THE ADMIBAL'S BKaULATIONS. 51

tinually passing backward and forward. After nine. Napoleon was not at liberty to leave the house, unless in company with a field-officer ; and no person what- ever was allowed to pass without the countersign. This state of affairs continued until daylight in the morning."*

Immediately after Napoleon had removed to Long- wood Sir George Cockbum drew up the following Regulations for securing his person : —

" That the officer stationed at Hutt's Gate be ordered not to allow any person to pass that post in the direction towards Longwood, excepting only officers in uniform, people belonging to the water- works or Company's farm, persons having business with the camp, and for the present the persons em- ployed on the improvemente carrying on at Long- wood, unless famished with a pass from the Governor, Commandant, or Admiral.

" The officer in charge of the guard at Longwood House to be directed not to suffer any person what- ever to pass within the lodge gates, or to come within any part of the premises of Longwood, unless they produce a pass, as in the preceding article, excepting only the Governor, Lieutenant-Governor, Comman- dant, Members of Council, and the Admiral and persons belonging to the establishment of the house, to the Company's farm or waterworks, and (for the present) those employed upon the improvements."

An addition was made to these Regulations on the 31st of December, and a pass from Count Bertrand was allowed to introduce persons into the precincts of

' Voice from St. Helena, vol. i. pp. 10, 16, 20, 21. Longwood is also fully desoribed, and plans of it are giren, in Count Montbolon's * lUcitd.'

£ 2

62 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. U.

Longwood. Sir George Cockbum stated also in a letter to Sir George Bingham, who commanded the troops, —

"An invitation from Comte de Bertrand to any person to come to Longwood may also be considered in fiiture as a sufficient pass ; but it is to be under- stood that every written document used. to pass any person or persons into Longwood premises is to be left with the guard at the lodge gates ; and I have further to request you will give directions that all these documents may be carefully preserved and in- variably transmitted to me by the earliest favour- able opportunity which may olBfer on the succeeding day."

Secret signals were established for communicating immediate notice of Bonaparte's movements; and Captain Poppleton was directed to inform Sir George Cockbum, by signal, once every morning and again ia the course of the evening, " whether all was well with regard to the General and the other foreigners at Longwood ;" and he was to intimate occasionally at other times their movements as he might think advisable, particularly when any of them passed (even if properly attended) the cordon of sentinels. Those signals were principally to the following elBfect : " All is well with respect to General Bonaparte and family." " General Bonaparte is unwell." " General Bonaparte is out, properly attended, beyond the cordon of sen- tries." " General Bonaparte is out, but within the cordon of sentries." " General Bonaparte has been out longer than usual, and is supposed to have passed the sentries, not properly attended." " General Bona- parte is missing." " General Bonaparte has returned home." " General Bonaparte is in want of "

Dk. 1815. SIGNALS. 53

In the event of the signal being made expressive of "(General Bonaparte being missing," immediately after it was answered at the commanding telegraphic officer's post, a blue flag was to be hoisted, which was to be repeated by every signal-post on the island as fast as they discovered it ; and this flag was to be continued flying until notice was obtained of the General, or till it was hauled down at the post of the commanding telegraphic officer ; and upon the above signal being made the signal officers at the diflferent posts were strictly enjoined to lose no time in com- municating the intelligence personally to the places nearest them where troops might be stationed, to the end that patrols might be immediately sent out in every direction to ensure his recovery, and to prevent the practicability of any person whatever escaping from the island. Whenever the signal was made of his " being out longer than usual, and supposed to have passed the sentinels, and not properly attended," it was to be repeated to the diifferent posts through out the island, and the same precautions were to be taken as in the event of the preceding signal ; but the blue flag was not to be hoisted. In the event of either of the foregoing signals being made with reference only to any of the attendants of the Gene- ral, the signals were to be repeated to the diflferent posts, and the same measures were to be also taken as in those cases, but the blue flag was not to be hoisted.

" On the 20th of December," says Count Mon- tholon, " the Admiral came to Longwood, but the Emperor would not receive him ; he was always angry that he had not the whole island for his prison, and reftised to believe that the restrictions upon his liberty were the orders of Ministers. He commanded me to

64 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. II.

write a series of complaints to the Admiral on this subject." * These were comprehended in a letter which was a complete catalogue of grievances, written in a dictatorial and insolent tone. It was as follows : —

'< To Admibal Sib Gbobos Cockbubh. " Sir, " Longwood, December 21, 1815.

'' Our condition at Longwood, distressing as it may be, would not draw from us any complaint, and we could bear it with the resignation of martyrs, were it not for the constant want of respect evinced for our rank and our suflFerings. If, to the injustice committed by your Gk)vemment in sending the Em- peror Napoleon to St. Helena, in defiance of the rights of nations, and which will excite the indigna- tion of all times and all people, they have added that of confining us to the most barren spot on the island, at least we had a right to expect those conso- lations of which even your Ministers had not dared to deprive us ; and yet we find that such intercourse with the inhabitants as was allowed by the instruc- tions you communicated to us is every day more restricted. You had arranged that we might walk in any part of the island, if accompanied by an English officer, or by Dr. O'Meara, surgeon of the British navy, and established by you at Longwood. General Gourgaud paid a visit to the Governor at Plantation House, accompanied by that officer ; this was in conformity with your own Regulations, and yet you reprimanded Mr. O'Meara; and the next day issued an order to the troops that he was no longer chosen to accompany us, and that we could not for the fixture go beyond the boundaries of Longwood

• R^cits, i, 200.

Dm. 1815. COUNT MONTHOLOira REMONSTRANCE. 55

wiihont being escorted by such officer as you youiv self should point out on each occasion to the Gamp- Major, It was agreed upon between us, Sir, that the porter at the gate of Longwood should be a French- man, and tiie sentinels should refer visitors to him to know if they could be received ; this was clearly allow- ing them to come freely. I accordingly wrote to the Captain of the 63rd regiment, on duty at Longwood, ^gg^g ^^ to &^^ orders tibat persons who should come to visit us might be directed to the lodge where I had placed the porter; but I then learnt^ to my great surprise, that it was expressly forbidden to come to Longwood to visit the Emperor or any of us without a passport from you. Can it be possible that we are denied the little consolation which we might derive from the society of a few individuals shut up like ourselves in this desert, or of that of a few of the inhabitants, who have frequently expressed their wish to come and see us ? The officers of the 53rd, en- camped within 500 paces of Longwood, wished to come here ; the permission to do so was refiised them. You told me yesterday. Sir, if I understood you rightly, that this order was given only under the apprehension that these visits might importune the Emperor ; but his Majesty had never complained of this kind of importunity while at the Briars, and this inconvenience, if even it had been deemed such, could easUy have been obviated by directions given by ourselves to the domestics of the establishment. The line of our enclosure seems purposely to have been traced with a view to avoid taking in such of the country houses as, from their position, might have formed the object of a walk. The boundary of the enclosure comprises only arid rocks and ravines which the eye cannot contemplate without horror ; the only

56 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. H.

yegetation is that of the gam-tree, which affords no shade ; water is very scarce and of bad quality. We might, at least, have expected that we should have been spared the inconveniences we had experienced in town from the continual mistakes in the orders given out, but, whatever care the oflScers and soldiers of the 53rd regiment take to avoid them, the mul- tiplicity and frequent change of orders which they receive are such, that they have not been able to prevent these annoyances from having occurred twice already. I appeal to yourself. Sir, does not every day bring with it some change in our position, or are we not confined to fixed rules ? The Emperor is ill at ease at Longwood, and is greatly incommoded by the smell of paint. The climate is more uncongenial at this particular spot than at any other part of the island. It is always windy, and it rains every day. We live in the midst of clouds and in a very damp atmosphere. The Emperor feels his health giving way, and we all suffer more or less. We want for everything, and the little furniture at Longwood seems to be made up of articles that have been worn out in servants' halls, and no French servant — On our arrival here his Majesty commissioned me to go and buy, at his own expense, such furniture and linen as was wanting, and as could be had in the shops of James Town. The next day I learned that Mr. Glo- ver, your secretary, had cautioned the shopkeepers not to let me have anything. There are, within the enclosure in which we are allowed to stroll, some wild goats and partridges ; we would have liked to have killed a few, and I had the honour to request of you yesterday to return us our fowling-pieces ; but if you cannot, Sir, grant my request without obliging us to give them up every evening to the captain on guard,

Die, X815. COUNT MONTHOLON'S REMONSTRANCE. 67

we prefer that yon should persist in the resolution you took on this subject in town with regard to General Gourgaud. In conclusion, Sir, I beg you will be so kind as to give me your answer to the following demands : — 1st, That the enclosure be enlarged, and that we may go without constraint to the Governor at Plantation House. 2nd, That any inhabitants of the island, or any officers of the 53rd regiment, who should desire to come to Longwood, be allowed to do so freely. 3rd, That Dr. O'Meara may be permitted, as heretofore, to accompany us ; the refusal given to him to do so being an insult to him as well as to us. 4th, That we be allowed to go to town with an Eng- lish officer, and that the steward or any other of the Emperor's domestics be also allowed to go to town, accompanied by an orderly, whenever it may be necessary for procuring provisions or for other wants of the house. 5th, The establishment of Lougwood, which is unwholesome and disagreeable in summer, will be intolerable in winter ; and I demand that we may be enabled to fix ourselves in a part of the island where there is verdure, less frightful scenery, and a temperature more healthy and agreeable. I should have repaired in person. Sir, to carry to you these remonstrances and demands, if I had been permitted to go to town, as was the case in the first days after our arrival. I beg you. Sir, to receive the assurances, &c.

" Le G*NfiRAL COMTE DE MONTHOLON."

' To this letter Sir George Cockburn sent the follow- ing reply : —

*< To General Coute de Montholon. " Sir, " St. Helena, December 22, 1815.

" A letter of yesterday's date which I have re- ceived bearing your signature I have read, I assure

58 CAPTivrrY op napoleon. chap. u.

you, Sir, with equal surprise and concern. With re- gard to what is therein stated respecting an ' Emperor Napoleon,* I have only to inform you that I have no cognizance of such a person. The very uncalled-for intemperance and indecency of the language which you have permitted yourself to use to me respecting my Government, I should not perhaps, Sir, condescend to notice, did I not think it right to inform you that I shall not in fiiture consider it necessary to answer any letters which I may receive couched in a similar strain of unfounded invective, and to assure you how much you are deceived if you really believe the Gk)- vernment of Great Britain have not ^ dared' (as you have been pleased to express it) to give every requi- site order for authorising whatever measures may be deemed necessary, as well for the furtherance of the purposes for which you and the other French officers and persons who nave accompanied you have been sent here, or for insuring a continuance of due tran- quillity and security to the island ; although I have the satisfaction to add, that the instructions hereupon breathe throughout the same moderation and justice which have hitherto characterized the whole conduct of my Government towards you, and which (notwith- standing your individual assertion to the contrary) will, I have no doubt, obtain the admiration of future ages, as well as of every unprejudiced person of the present. It is not for me, Sir, to explain the grounds on which I have found feult with Dr. O'Meara or any other British subject on this island. Yourself, Sir, as well as any of the French officers and other persons who have accompanied you to this island, have (until I judge it necessary to give contrary directions) free permission to visit not only the town, but every part of the island (those places alone excepted where there

J)Bo. 1815. THE ADMEflAL'S REPLY. 59

are fortifications), it being only required that you be accompanied by a British officer whenever beyond the boundaries allotted you around Longwood ; but I must still decline consenting to a physician being considered as an officer within the intention of this regulation. No officer nor respectable inhabitant of this island whatsoever has been or will be prevented fipom visit- ing at Longwood House, upon being disposed so to do, provided they conform to such regulations (with respect to themselves) as the Governor (if inhabitants) or the Commandant or myself (if officers) may con- sider it right to require of them, according to the cir- cumstances of the moment. The orders given upon your arrival at Longwood have neither been increased nor altered in the slightest degree, excepting only upon the points to which at your repeated personal solicitation I so reluctantly consented ; and as I ex- plained to you, Sir, in the most forcible manner pos- sible, at the moment I so swerved to oblige you, the reasons which induced me so long and strongly to combat your wishes to obtain alterations in the regu- lations lien established, I could but little have ex- pected to have received from you the remarks there- npon contained in your letter; and to the question you conclude this subject with, * whether changes are' not daily taking place with regard to *your position,' I do not hesitate in answering most point- edly *iVa,' nor do I think it at all likely any will take place, because it does not appear to me at present necessary that any should. Longwood is allowed to be beyond comparison the most pleasant as well as the most healthy spot of this most healthful island. Every pains have been taken to make the house as comfortable as possible within the short time which has been allowed for improving it, and I derived great

60 CAFnVITT OP NAPOLEON. Chap. n. ,

satisfaction, when I accompanied General Bonaparte to ity from his having expressed himself to me so much contented with it. I am, Sir, of course pro- portionably mortified to learn your unfavourable opinion of it, which, however, I am not without hope may soon change with the weather, which has of late been rainy beyond precedent at this season of the year. Mr. Glover, my secretary, assures me that what you state to have learnt, respecting his having desired merchants in James Town not to deliver to you articles you wished to buy with your own money, is without foundation in truth; to prove which, he requests only to know the name of the person who gave you this information. As when I had the honour to see you the day before yesterday, and to receive from you the request respecting the fowling-pieces, in which I immediately acquiesced, the proposal of their being lodged out of the house, though within reach when wanted, originated with yourself, I have not been less surprised at the paragraph on this subject than at the rest of your letter ; this being, however, the season at which it is contrary to the laws of the island to shoot, it becomes perhaps the less necessary to enter into further discussion on this head. I have now. Sir, followed your letter to its conclusion, though not without the pain natural to a person upon dis- covering his constant and unremitted exertions likely to feil in one of their principal olyects ; I trust, how- ever, what I have stated upon the diflFerent objects to which you have referred will at least prove sufficiently explicit to prevent any further misconceptions. I have tlie honour, &c. « ^ Cockburn."

It appears that Count Montholon soon afterwards felt somewhat ashamed of his letter of the 21st of De-

Jan. 1816. COUNT MONTHOLON'S BETRACTATION. 61

cember, for on the 12th of January, 1816, Sir George Cockbum wrote to Earl Bathurst, and told him that Count Montholon had explained to him that it was written in a moment of petulance on the part of Bona parte, and that he (the Count) was aware of the reproach to which he subjected himself by writing it ; also that he considered the party at Longwood to be in point of fact very well oflf, and to have everything necessary for them, though he was anxious that there should be no restrictions whatever as to Bonaparte going unattended by an officer wherever he pleased throughout the island. "As, however," said Sir Gkorge Cockbum, "this is incompatible with my instructions, and also, in my opinion, with the fixture safety of his person, I have firmly resisted it, and shall most certainly continue to do so until the arrival of Sir Hudson Lowe, whom I am now daily expect- ing."^

Owing to a mistake Bonaparte was stopped by a sentinel on the 12th of January while riding on horse- back near Hutt*s Gate. As soon as Sir George Cockbum heard of the circumstance he directed his secretary to write the following note to the orderly officer at Longwood, and he went there himself on the 14th to express his regret at what had taken place^: —

" The Admiral was much annoyed this aftemoon to find that General Bonaparte had been yesterday re-

' Count Montholon says (BScits, i. 213) that Napoleon dictated a long letter to Ck)unt Bertrand on the 24th of January for the Admiral, com- plaining of several petty and useless vexations ; but no letter of that date has been found amongst the Lowe papers.

■ B^dts, 1. 208, 209. Count Montholon adds that Bonaparte accepted the Admiral's excuses upon condition that the soldier should not be ptmished. Count Las Cases says he was a drunken corporal who bad misunderstood the countersign.

%2 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. H.

fused to pass the sentry at Hutt*s Gate. He therefore begs you will have it explained to him that it was entirely a mistake, either of the ofl&cer at Hutt's Gate, or of the orders given him ; at the same time you will state that General Bonaparte and all his suite (includ- ing servants) have the liberty of passing and repassing anywhere within the cordon of sentries ; consequently they can come this way as for as the sentry at the Alarm House."

On the 13th of March Count Bertrand wrote to Sir Gkorge Cockburn, and asked him whether he could charge himself with a sealed letter from the Emperor to the Prince Regent, with the assurance that it would not be opened, but be forwarded to the hands of the Prince Regent.

The Admiral said in his reply, —

" As I have already had the honour to remark to you, in my letter of the 6th of November last,^ I have no knowledge of the person designated by you * the Emperor,' there being no person on this island I can consider entitled to such dignity, Kings being actually at the head of our respective countries, and there being more than one nation in Europe, and elsewhere, ruled by acknowledged Emperors. I enclose, however, for your guidance, and for that of any of the other distinguished foreigners similarly situated with your- self, extracts of my instructions with regard to the correspondence permitted to you, from which I do not consider myself authorized to swerve."

To this Count Bertrand rejoined, —

" Monsieur TAmiral, " St. Helena, March 20, 1816.

" I have the honour to acknowledge the receipt of

> See p. 39, ante.

Mar. 1816. COUNT BEBTBAND*S COMPLAINTS. 63

your letter of the 14th March, by which you refuse to forward such sealed letters as we would address to your Sovereign or your Government. I accordingly abstained, on the departure of the Ceylon for Europe, from sending the Emperor's letter to the Prince Re- gent, The Emperor has verbally desired Captain Hamilton^ to make known to the Prince Regent the strange treatment to which he is subjected, and that he will have the honour of writing to him so soon as any Englishman of distinction shall visit the island who will take charge of his letter. Nothing, cer- tainly, that is unjust, or contrary to the rights of man and the custom of civilized nations, can surprise the Emperor, on the part of those who have violated in his person the rights of hospitality — rights held sacred even among barbarians. Nevertheless, on reading with attention the extract of the instructions which you have taken the trouble to send me, we think we do not find in it any authority for your conduct on this occasion. How, indeed, can it be conceived that a government would prohibit the direct address to it of complaints, if these were of a nature not to be seen by the person who, at a distance of 2000 leagues from the metropolis, being armed with all power, might commit the most extraordinary excesses ? In feet, the spirit of the instructions, by directing that com- plaints be addressed unsealed, is entirely in the in- terest of the complainants, and in order that, the complaints being accompanied by your observations, your Government might aflford the more prompt satis- faction : this article of your instructions, therefore, so far from being opposed to the interests of those who have occasion to complain, is but a modification in

' Of the Havannali frigate.

64 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. II.

their fevour. Your Government does not prohibit, nor can it prohibit, our sending to it sealed letters when such is the wish of those who write them, still less can such prohibition have reference to letters addressed to your Sovereign; besides which, your instructions speak of demands which might be made ; but a letter to the Prince Regent or to your Govern- ment may contain other matters with which you ought not to be made acquainted. It appears therefore that you have no right, either by the nature of things or by the spirit of your instructions, to intercept the correspondence with the Prince Regent or with your Ministers; neither would you, if there were in this part of the world a General your superior in this com- mission, have any right to prevent recourse being had to him. One might well ask if such a discussion as the present is being carried on under the laws of European nations or in the wilds of Tartary ? Please to accept, &c.

"Le Comte Bertrand."

Sir George Cockbum answered that, "notwith- standing the arguments adduced in this letter, he conceived that nothing could be more clear and con- clusive than the following extract from his instruc- tions : — * Any letters addressed to him (General Bonaparte) or his attendants must be first delivered to the Admiral, or to the Gt)vemor, as the case may be, who will read them before they are delivered to the per- sons to whom they are addressed. All letters written by the General or his attendants must be subject to the same regulation.' '*^

' This paragraph deserves particular attention, for the enforcement of the rule by Sir Hudson Lowe was one of the grievances most bitterly com- plained of by the French, and he was accused of having innovated in this respect upon the practice of his predecessor.

Kar. 1816. REPLY TO COUNT BEBTRAND. 65

He added, —

"I hare no hesitation, Sir, in agreeing with yon as to the considerate and benign principle towards you which influenced His Majesty's Government in fram- ing the other paragraph of these instructions alluded to by you ; but I must beg to observe to you. Sir, that, although the spirit of that particular instruc- tion, as you very justly observe, is intended to prove favourable to you, yet it does not lose sight of the necessary justice towards myself, or towards whomso- ever may remain charged with your detention at St. Helena; it being equally calculated to prevent the possibility of any compladnt you might think proper to allege with regard to our conduct towards you here being known in Europe six months without observation or answer from us.

"Although, Sir, it would have been certainly very fer from entering my imagination, had it not been for a paragraph in your last letter, I now deem it right, previous to concluding this, to beg of you to be as- sured that nothing yourself nor any of the foreign gentlemen similarly situated may think proper to write concerning me can, in the slightest degree, affect the line of conduct towards you I consider to be called for from me by the tenor of my instructions, or the consideration and respect towards you which I consider to be called for by your present situation."

When Sir George Cockbum transmitted a copy of this correspondence to Earl Bathurst, he said, —

" I consider General Bonaparte to be angry at my continuing to resist the frequent applications which have been made to me personally by his attendants that he might be permitted to range at pleasure over the whole interior of the island without being attended

VOL. I. F

66 CAPTIVnT OP NAPOLEON. Chaf. U.

by a British officer ; but, as I remarked to y onr Lord- ship in my letter of the 12th of January last, consi- dering such permission to be incompatible with my instmctions, and also with the safety of his person, I have felt it my duty still to refuse my acquiescence thereto/'

It is important to notice how clearly it appears from these letters that Sir Qeorge Oockbum's mear sures were displeasing to Bonaparte ; and it will be seen hereafter how little reason he and his suite had to complain of increased rigour on the part of Sir Hudson Lowe. But feeling the inconvenience of pre- sent restrictions, they were apt to forget the past, and imagine or pretend that they had eigoyed more liberty under Sir Qeorge Cockbum. Napoleon afterwards indulged in the grossest abuse of Sir Hudson Lowe, and often contrasted that officer's conduct towards him with the treatment he had received from Sir G^oi^e Cockbum in a manner highly &vourable to the latter, and yet he had spoken in nearly similar terms of Sir George Cockbum himself/ This fact is shown by a letter from O'Meara to Mr. Finlaison dated the 16th of March, 1816, which contains some interesting information not in his printed work : —

** Notwithstanding the assertion of some that Napo- leon Buonaparte is contented with his lot, I can assure you that directly the reverse is the case, and that he inveighs most bitterly against the Briti^ Ministry for sending him here, particularly to me on various occa- sions. He has been for some time back at Longwood,

> Bonaparte's diBflatisfaction with Sir George Gockbum appears, more- orer, from the works of O'Meara, Count Las Gases, and Count MonthoUn, as well as from the correspondence between the Admiral and Count Bertrand. Cotmt Las Cases has filled several pages of his Journal with a catalogue of all " the wrongs {torU) with which they had to reproach him."

Mab. 1816. O'MEARA'8 LETTER TO FINLAISON. 67

where he is tolerably well lodged, considering the island ; though, to tell yon the truth, the moveables which compose the fdmiture of the house are not such as could be wished for, notwithstanding that great ex- ertions were made on the part of Sir George Cockburn to procure the best ; but the fact is that the island does not afford them.

"He was greatly displeased with the Admiral some weeks back, in consequence of orders having been given prohibiting all persons from going to Longwood without a pass. He sent for me in great haste, and, with considerable emotion, expressed himself nearly in the following terms : — * That I should denumd from the Admiral that the orders prohibiting all persons to visit him or any of his suite should be forthwith rescinded, as well to the officers as to the inhabitants ; that he was desirous of seeing the officers of the 53rd regi- ment, as well as such of the inhabitants as from their situation in life might visit him, and such as he thought proper. That it was absurd to prohibit people from calling upon him, while at the same time he was at liberty himself to go out and call on them.' *It is,' added he, * an insult, and one of those which are daily offered to myself or some of my followers. I will never receive any person coming with a pass from the Ad- miral, as I wiU immediately set down the person receiving it as being like the donor, and a spy upon me. Tell him, that his sending to inform me that the sentinels are placed in order to prevent people from annoying me with visits is only adding vyrong to inmlt 1 I will choose myself what kind of visitors I like. A gross insult has been offered to me by Glover, the secretary, going round to the different shops' (this was, however, partly a misrepresentation to him), ^and cautioning the shopkeepers not to give any goods to

F 2

68 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. U.

the French oflScers, even if ready money is oflFered. Yes,* continued he, *one of them sent me word of it. I wish to furnish the house myself, and pay myself for it. They have collected all tiie crazy fomiture in the island for my use; and probably said at the same time, We will gather all the rotten articles in a mass — they are good enough for Buonaparte and the French. Was the Admiral to heap every kind of benefit on me, the manner in which he does it would make me con- ceive each and every one an insult. Everything is given to us as if we were demanding alms. I have money and friends sufficient to pay for everything I want. I want nothing from the English Government. When I was at Elba, I had deputations from the four first commercial cities in France, offering me whatever money I wanted ; and fix)m the Americans also. The contemptuous manner in which everything is offered is peculiarly grating. Some forms are necessary with strangers and the unfortunate.' Here he related an anecdote about the Marquis of Semonville, who, when detained by the Austrians and ,* was never- theless treated with the most marked respect, served every day in plate with the greatest luxuries, and every species of attention paid to him. * Let them at least not treat me with contempt, even if they give me nothing. Let them refuse me everything, but do it in a polite manner. Tell him,' continued he, 'that it is not generous to insult the unfortunate.'

" Then becoming more warm, he said, * Who is the Admiral ? I never heard his name mentioned {is con- quering in a battle, either singly or in general action. 'Tis true he has rendered his name infamous in Ame- rica, which I heard of, and he will now render it so

' The words omitted could not be deciphered.

Mar, 1816. HIS COMPLAINTS TO OlffEARA. 69

here on this detestable rock. I believe, however, that he is a good sailor/ Stopping, then, with much agita- tion, and looking at me earnestly — *Next to your Government exiling me here, the worst thing they could have done, and the most insufferable to my feelings, is sending me with such a man as him ! I will make my treatment kno¥m to all Europe. It will be a reflection and a stain to his posterity for centuries. What ! does he want to introduce Turkish laws into the rock? Even prisoners under sentence of death are allowed to communicate, by the laws of England and all other civilized nations. Tell him,' continued he, *what I have told you, and that I will make a remonstrance to the Grovemor here — to Colonel Bingham, and the civil power — if he does not alter within twenty-four hours the orders which he has given, and to conceive the letter written by Montholon to him as written by my- self, and not to blame him.* I told the Admiral every- thing he had said except the personal part. His object was, that every person might be permitted to come and see him at Longwood without a pass from the Admiral, and to get some of the orders changed, which in fact I believe it was not in the Admiral's power to comply with.

" Since that, however, matters have been arranged by the Admiral's permitting such persons as he thinks proper to go to Marshal Bertrand, who lives about a mile from Longwood, and on receiving a pass from him they are allowed to enter Longwood. He has also discovered since this that the Admiral's conduct has been most grossly and shamefully misrepresented and blackened to him. The people he is surrounded by at present give me some faint idea of what the Court of St. Cloud must have been during his omnipo- tent sway. Everything even here is disguised and

70 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. IL

mutilated in the representation to him, particularly by Montholon.^ Marshal Bertrand, however, is an excep- tion to this, and is, in my opinion, really an honest and good man.

" He frequently breaks out into invectives against the English Gk)vemment for sending him to this island, which he pronounces (with some reason) to be the most detestable spot in the universe. ^Behold the English Gk)vemment,' said he, gazing around at the frightful and stupendous rocks which encompassed him. * This is their liberality to the unfortunate, who, con- fiding in what he so blindly imagined to be their nar tional character, in an evil hour gave himself up to them. But your Ministers laugh at your laws. I thought once that the English were a free nation, but I see now that you are the greatest slaves in the world,' said he to me one day ; * you all of you tremble at the sight of that man. In my greatest power I could not do such things as I have seen done to your sailors and others since I have come to this Isle de Brouillard.'

'* Another time, talking to me about the island, he said, * In fact I expect nothing less from your Govern- ment than that they will send out an executioner to despatch me. They send me here to a horrible rock, where even the water is not good ; they send out a sailor with me who does not know how to treat a man like me, and who puts me a camp under my noae^ so that I cannot put my head out without seeing my jailers. Here we are treated like felons ; a proclama- tion issued for nobody to come near or touch us, as if we were so many lepers^ or had the itch 1* When I brought back the Admiral's verbal answer to him (to the conversation that was related above), viz. that it

* It is very necessary to bear in mind this important statement of O'Meara. Ample proofs of its truth wiU appear in the following pages.

Mar. 1816. CONDUCT OF THE SUITE. 71

would be better for him to complain to him, the Ad- miral, if he had any grievances, without the interven- tion of a third person, he said, * No, no. I recollect, when I was First Consul, that I had a conversation with your Ambassador — Lord Titwort (Whitworth), I think,* says he, *was his name — in which I con- ducted myself with great cabnness and propriety, without more heat or intemperance in my langui^e than I am at present making use of to you ; but in a short time afterwards I saw in the English paper a pars^raph as long as that,' said he, getting np and stretching out his arm very significantly, ^ filled with lies.' However, the Admiral a few days afterwards had an audience with him, and satisfied him several of the things he had imputed to him had been misrepre* sented, and they parted better Mends than I expected. " To give you an instance of how mnch, even in his present comparative obscurity, attempts are made to conceal the truth fi*om him, and to give him false im- pressions concerning every occurrence, the following will be a good example: — ^Some time back General Montholon complained to the Admiral that the rest of the people of the house were continually disturbed by some person or persons endeavouring at night to get into ^e room of a female servant of his, and also declaring his apprehension that the house might be robbed, and perhaps Napoleon assassinated. He there^ fore solicited the Admiral to give directions that the sentinels nightly placed about the house might be directed to approach close to the doors and windows, instead of keeping as much out of sight as the nature of circumstances would admit, as heretofore. In con- sequence of this, the Admiral directed that every night a corporal should be sent up to the house in oi^er to give directions to the sentinels, after a certain

72 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. U.

hour, which he (Montholon) was to point out, that no persons should be suffered to go out of, or enter, the house. Now you must know that it is Buonaparte's greatest annoyance to see a sentinel placed near him, and at his request before measures were taken to keep them as much out of his sight as was consistent with the duty imposed upon them ; therefore, upon finding the sentries nearly stuck into the windows, and block- ading closely all the doors, he was greatly offended, and expressed himself very warmly on the subject. Montholon, dreading his indignation, told him that it was the Admiral's orders, without having any request made to him to do so; and he also told General Gh)urgaud to remonstrate strongly against it, as being a breach of promise on the part of the Admiral, and intended as an annoyance. This came to my ears, and intelligence of the same was immediately de- spatched by me to the Admiral, who at first could scarcely credit it, but afterwards sent me up word to undeceive General Buonaparte as soon as I had an op- portunity of speaking to him, which I did the same day. Napoleon broke out into several invectives against Montholon, whom he called a *coglione,* imbecile, &c. &c., and only fit to go into the kitchen and look after the pots ; adding, that he had worse blood in his veins than the black fellow he had sent off — alluding to a negro he had discharged for caterwauling I This has in a great manner opened his eyes to Montholon, as he scarcely spoke to him for several days ; and on one occasion, when Montholon was going into the town for some business, Napoleon said to him, * Now, Montho- lon, do not bring me back any lies as news, as Mar- shal Bertrand is going to town to-morrow, and I will then hear the truth.* Napoleon has been in very good health, but I have trouble enough with some others of

Mab. 1816. O'MEABA'S SALARY, 73

them. General Goargand has been very ill with dysentery, but is now recovering ; Madame Montho- Ion also has been ill with the same complaint ; she is likely to bring another Montholon into the world shortly. Madame Bertrand has been in general good health, and bears her lot much better than I expected. In fiujt, thongh a little passionate, I believe that she is at bottom a good woman ; she is certainly free from dissimulation. I had an offer from the Admiral of 328Z. a-year as a compensation for remaining here. This I think, however, is a very inadequate sum. The assistant-surgeons of the Company have very nearly as much, and the regimental surgeons have upwards of 500/. — ^permanent situations, with two assistants to perform their duties ; and the medical superintendent 850?. I have to perform every duty of physician, surgeon, apothecary, and indeed orderly-man, I may say ; and, in fact, was my duty to be so laborious as it has been for some weete back, I would not (as the Admiral's own surgeon told him) take a thousand a year to perform it. In fact, if the (Government does not choose to give me what Buonaparte offered me him- seU^ viz. 12,000 fruncs, and repeated once in a letter from General Montholon, which has been forwarded to the Admiralty, I must decline holding the situation any longer. If I must be a prisoner, it is only the hopes of emolument which will induce me to continue in this cage. You will perceive that the greatest part, if not the whole, of this letter would be unfit to meet the public eye, perhaps would not be altogether agreeable to the Government also ; however, of this you are, of course, the best judge. I merely tell you in confidence of what really happened — particularly as Napoleon now is able, with a dictionary, to read the English papers, and, of course, in consequence of

74 CAPnVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. II.

nobody ever having been present during the greater part of the conversations which have taken place between him and me, would immediately discover that I was the author, and I know would be greatly offended. It must be evident to you that, unless I was on good terms with him, it would be very dis- agreeable, if not impossible, to remain as his surgeon. Therefore may I beg of you to confide this only to such persons as you know will not put the contents in the newspapers? Probably you might alter such parts of it as did not take place inmiediately between him and me, or such as might appear to have been mentioned publicly, to answer any purpose you might wish.

^^ I will take the advantage of the Northumberland leaving this to send Mrs. Finlaison something by a safe hand. I hope that you are in better health, and that Mrs. Finlaison and all the little ones are quite well. If I have time, I will enclose in another packet a letter for Captain Maitland and my sister ; but at present, in consequence of General Qourgaud and Madame Montholon's illness, together with several very serious accidents having happened up here, I have been vainly endeavouring to get time to write. Indeed, you can expect nothing from me but uncon- nected letters, as I am disturbed every ten minutes with calls of some kind, either real or fancied. I really do not know why I should not receive the same pay as a regimental surgeon on shore here ; I know that I have ten times more to do. Between sickness, illness, and whims, fears, &c., I have very little time to myself. I have been offered by Buonaparte himself a very handsome salary in addition, which I have refused to himself, as I do not think it proper for a Britii^ officer to receive money from him without the sanction of

Mab. 1816. GENERAL GOUBGAUD'S ILLNESS. 75

Government. I want the Government to make my situation equal to others of the same rank here, and to he under no obligation to any person else. By the bye, do not be surprised if there is some noise made in England abont Buonaparte's household being a little stinted in their living, and in some other particulars. I forgot to mention to you that he is at present com- posing the History of his Life, several parts of which I have seen. He dictates to the others, and after- wards corrects himself what they have written."

On the 26th of March O'Meara wrote to the same correspondent : —

** Gourgaud is now recovering from dysentery, of which he has had a severe attack. During his illness I never saw a man betray so much fear of dying as he did on various occasions : in feet, I was completely scandalized at seeing a man of the sword so exces- sively timorous. One night a large black-beetle got into the bed, and crawled up alongside of him. His distressed imagination immediately magnified this in- sect into a devil, or some other formidable apparition, armed with talons, long teeth, and ready to tear away his lingering soul from its mortal abode. He shrieked, became terribly agitated, convulsed; a cold sweat bedewed his pallid fex^e ; and, when I entered, he pre- sented all the appearance of a man about to expire, with the most terrific ideas of what could be his future lot; and it was not until after a considerable time that he was restored to some degree of composure. A second instance occurred, with this difference, that the latter was a frightful dream, in which he fancied that he was dragged under the wheel of a huge watermill, where he was crushed to pieces, and lay expiring ; at the same time he fancied that his ears were deafened

76 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. H.

with the confused voices of numberless people crying, * He is gone ; his life is demanded, and nothing can snatch him from perdition/

"Disease will doubtless enfeeble the energies of the soul^ and produce considerable despondence even in the bravest men ; but that a man really brave could manifest so much fear of dying, and such childish depression of spirits, I can scarcely credit. He repeat- edly wept, and called upon his mother and sister. This is the man who, when he came here first, most ostentatiously produced a sword to the Miss Bal- combes, where he had himself represented in the act of killing a Cossack who was endeavouring to take Buonaparte prisoner, with a pompous inscription de- scribing the particulars. At the end of the blade he made them observe a spot, which he explained to the young ladies as being stained with the blood of two Englishmen slain by him at the battle of Waterloo. He also added, that at the same battle he might readily have made the Duke of Wellington prisoner, but that indeed he saw the business was decided, and was unwilling to produce any more effusion of human blood. Credat. During his illness, however, he seemed to have forgotten all his exploits, as one day, when whining and lamenting his present state, he said, with many tears, that he did not know for what reason he was exiled and treated like a felon ; that he had never done harm to mortal."

And now let us say a few words respecting the writer of these and many other letters which will be quoted in the present work. Barry Edward 0*Meara entered the army as assistant-surgeon in the year 1804, at the age of eighteen. While in Sicily, at Messina, with his regiment in 1808, a duel was fought between

1818. OlIEARA'S EARLY CAREEB. 77

two of the officers, to one of whom, the challenger, O'Meara acted as second. He was in consequence tried bja conrt-martial, and sentenced to be cashiered. He then became a naval surgeon, and served in the Mediterranean and the West Indies, where he appears to have discharged his duties to the satisfaction of his superiors. He was in three different ships successively under the command of Captain Maitland, who received Napoleon on board the Bellerophon, and that officer had a high opinion of him. In a letter which 0*Meara has published Captain Maitland says that, during the fifteen years he had commanded ships of war, he had never had the pleasure of sailing with an officer in his situation who so fully met his expectations. And he speaks warmly of his attention and tenderness to the men under his charge. So much, in fairness to O'Meara, we are bound to state, and it is all we know respecting his previous career before he became the medical attendant of Napoleon at St. Helena.

In a letter which appeared in the * Morning Chronicle ' on the '17th of March, 1823, he attempted to give an explanation of the letters which he had written from time to time to Sir Hudson Lowe, Sir Thomas Reade, and Major Gorrequer, while he was with Bonaparte at liOngwood, and which will be found to be in remarkable contrast to the assertions and opinions contained in his printed work. He said —

"I had been five months at St. Helena when this Governor arrived there. Although I had gone out with Sir George Cockbum, who knew all the prelimi- naries to my appointment ; although I had remained so "iany months the acknowleged surgeon to Napoleon ; although every person fully recognised me — what was the very first step of this Sir Hudson Lowe ? He said

78 CAPTTVITT OP NAPOLEON. Chaf. H.

that he had no official knowledge of my appointment ; and that, if I ooold not show him my vnitten appoint^ fnentj he would, in his own classical phrase, ^ bundle me off the island back to England.' ^ He well knew I had then no tcriiien appointment. In Tain did I refer him to Sir Gkorge Cockbum, and to all the officers, British as well as French, as to the fact of my nomi- nation by Napoleon, and its confirmation by the Ad- miralty. All this testimony was inadmissible : nothing would answer but the written appointment. I asked, if he did send me off the island, what would become of Napoleon in case of illness ? * Oh,' said he, * Gene- ral Buonaparte shall be attended by my own surgeon, who speaks Italian, and was for several years with me in the Gorsican Bangers. It was some time since I had seen the play of 'Richard the Third ^^ and the meaning of the words did not at once strike me.* Nar poleon was wiser. I did, however, ask him, anxious as I naturally was not to abandon my illustrious charge, whether I could in no way conciliate his protection. He replied that he was determined that no British subject should associate with Napoleon who did not subsequently report his conversation ; that I might remain by rendering myself useful to the Gh> vemment and himself, and by reporting everything that came under my observation, or that made against the French, who had the impudence to complain, though they were much better treated than they de- served, for which they showed no gratitude. The

' It will be seen hereafter that this assertion ib unfounded. ' I suppose O'Meara here alludes to the conversation between Bichard III. and Buckingham, where the former says, —

** Cousin, thou wast not wont to be so dull : — Shall I be plain ? I wish the bastards dead ; And I would have it suddenly perform'd,"

1816. CMBARA'S EXPLANATION. 79

proposal was abhorrent, but still the alternative was worse, and I determined upon consulting the Emperor, I did so ; and never shall I forget that instinct per- ception for which he was so remarkable, and which at the moment lighted up his countenance. ^ Never, said Napoleon, ^ never shall the hody-physician of that Governor attend me. I have seen hie face, and the proposal needs no other commentary. You may do anything, only keep me out of the hands of that man's body-physician. Doctor, humanity will excuse the pious fraud to which I command you. Speak as you will of us all ; gratify his nature by abusing or decry- ing us ; but keep me out of the hands of his body- physician.' The intenseness with which Napoleon spoke convinced me he was agitated and in earnest, wd I thus consented to make occasional communica- tions, which, if unexplained, would bear the appear- ance of duplicity towards him. It is a concession, I admit, of which the humblest man might well be ashamed, but I did it at the intercession of an illus- trious individual, whose fallen fortunes made every generous man his friend, while they left no honour- able man his enemy. Let it be remarked that all the letters quoted are dated prior to the 9th of October, 1816; and until the carrying into execu- tion the Eestrictions of that day, the Governor's conduct, although tyrannical, was still that of a human being.'*

And in the same letter O'Meara added, —

" The reader will see that they have not produced any letters of mine, except strictly official, subsequent to October 1816.^ Then came the infamous, the

» O'Meara here refers to an article in the * Quarterly Review * for October, 1822, which was reprinted in Febraary, 1828.

80 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Char, H.

nation-degrading Restrictions, after which I determiaed to abjure Sir Hudson Lowe and his gang as soon as my appointment had been confirmed in writing, aod that I thought myself secured by the support of Lor^d Liverpool/'

Now it will be observed that here are two distinct assertions, — the one, that Napoleon commanded O'Meara to commit a " pious fraud " in gratifying Sir Hudson Lowe by reports defamatory of the French, in order that the Governor, being thus propitiated, might allow him to remain as medical attendant at Long- wood ; the other, that it was in consequence of the Restrictions which were imposed in October, 1816, that O'Meara determined no longer to keep up appear- ances, but thenceforth, as soon as he could do it with safety, "abjure Sir Hudson Lowe and his gang." Neither of these statements will for a moment bear examination. With respect to the former, the reader will judge when he peruses the letters themselves, and sees the abandon of their style and tone. He will then decide whether they do not bear the unmistakable impress of being the genuine and spontaneous eflFusions of a man ready, if not eager, to communicate all he knew on the subjects to which they refer, and whether their internal evidence does not prove that the author wrote at the time exactly as he felt. As to the latter, it will be shown that neither at the date of the Re- strictions, nor during his correspondence for a consi- derable period afterwards, did O'Meara find any fault with them, nor was there any change whatever in the tone of his letters until many months subsequent to October, 1816, Moreover, we have the means of testing his veracity in a manner which is seldom pos- sible. We possess an authentic record of his real

1816. OBJECT OF O'MEAEA'S •VOICE.' 81

opinions and of the facts that came under his eye in a copy of the long and voluminous jpnm^^ correspond- ence which lie kept up with his friend Mr. Finlaison, the well-known actuary, who was then a clerk in the Admiralty, of which we shall have more to say by-and-by. We can thus easily ascertain the truth of the statements which a few years afterwards he published to the world, and are able, as it were, to confront the witness with himself.^

I have already said that the object which this writer had in view when he printed his * Yoice' was to avenge himself upon Sir Hudson Lowe, as the supposed author of his disgrace. And the means of accomplishing this were not difficult to a man who was content to sacrifice truth, honour, and honesty in the attempt. He had been in constant intercourse with Napoleon, and had had many confidential inter- views with Sir Hudson Lowe. He knew perfectly well the real character of every alleged grievance and complaint, and he had taken copious notes of transac- tions and conversations as they occurred. What then was more easy than to re-cast these memoranda and garble them to suit the object he had in view? to suppress some passages and add others, so as to alter the tone and complexion of the original, and yet pre- serve throughout a substratum of fact ? And this is what O'Meara has done. It is a serious charge to bring against a writer, and one which ought not to be lightly made nor readily believed. But happily for the cause of truth, in this case, proof, amounting to demonstration, of what is here asserted, can be sup- plied. It may be thought, indeed, that this is impos- sible, for we have no access to O'Meara's notes, and

* This is done with admirable force and effect in the ' Quarterly Review,' No. LV., pp. 219-246 (October, 1822).

VOL. I. O

82 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. II.

how then, it may be asked, can we show what they originally contained ? But although we cannot pro- duce these memoranda, there exists a series of confi- dential letters written by him from time to time, during a great part of the period embraced by his book, in which he relates conversations and events as they happened, and the narrative is obviously taken from the same notes of which he professed afterwards to give to the world a true transcript when he pub- lished his work. We are thus enabled to compare and contrast his written and printed statements of the same occurrences,. and the result will show that, to gratify his malice against Sir Hudson Lowe, he pub- lished a most unfair, not to say false, version of his own notes, and that no reliance whatever can be placed on his veracity. Moreover, at most of the conversations recorded by him. Major Gorrequer, the military secretary of the Governor, was present, and he wrote down at the time, or immediately afterwards, full minutes of all that passed, so that we can cite him as a witness, and oppose his statements to those of O'Meara in his book.

Some things, indeed, are incapable of confutation : — ^as for instance where O'Meara says that Sir Hudson Lowe made a remark "with a peculiar grin,*' or pointed to a passage in a review "with a triumphant laugh," or " darted a furious look," or met him " with an exulting air." But what cannot be disproved may notwithstanding be disbelieved. The credit due to such assertions depends upon the fact that we put feith in the truthfulness of the narrator, and common sense as well as common charity requires that, when a writer is convicted in numerous instances of having borne false testimony against another, we should refuse to believe accusations which rest upon his testimony alone.

I

Afbii, 1816. ACTS OF PAELIAMENT. 83

The same remark applies to the coarse and vulgar expressions which O'Meara so firequently puts into the mouth of Sir Hudson Lowe when repeating con- versations at which they only were present, and which are intended to convey the idea that the Bri- tish officer who had been intrusted with the difficult and delicate charge of ensuring, the safe custody of Napoleon Bonaparte was a man without the refine- ment of a gentleman^ a sort of military Squire West- em, to whom the use of low and violent language was habitual. All that can be said on this subject is, that nothing is to be found in his correspondence or any of the papers he has left which can justify this opinion, or lead us to the belief that such expressions were uttered by Sir Hudson Lowe, and were not the inven- tion of O'Meara.

Parliament met on the 1st of February, 1816, and on the 11th of April two Acts received the royal assent — the one entitled ' An Act for the more effectually detaining in custody Napoleon Buona- parte,' and the other *An Act for regulating the intercourse with the island of St. Helena during the time Napoleon Buonaparte shall be detained there.'^ Next day a warrant was issued to Sir Hudson Lowe, under the authority given by the former Act to the Secretary of State, empowering and requiring him safely to detain and keep Napoleon Bonaparte as a prisoner of war in the island of St. Helena during his Majesty's pleasure, and to treat and deal with him as a prisoner of war, under such restrictions and in such manner as had been or should from time to time be signified in that behalf by his Majesty, under the hand

* The former of these Acta will be found .amongst the Letters and Documents at the end of the volume.

G 2

84 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. D.

of one of his Mjyesty's Principal Secretaries of State ; — ^and in case of the escape or rescue of the said Xa- poleon Bonaparte, to retake, detain, and keep him in custody-

But before we enter upon the details of Sir Hudson Lowe's eventful government it is necessary to become acquainted with his previous history, in order to see how fer the English ministry were justified in appointing him to an office of such trust and respon- sibility.

Chap. in. MEMOIB OF SIB HUDSON LOWE. 85

CHAPTER III.

MEMOIB OF 8IE HUDSON LOWE UP TO THE PEBIOD OF HIS BECOMING GOVEBNOB OF ST. HELENA.

Sib Hudson Lowe was, as he himself tells us in a frag- ment of an autobiography which he left, bom in the army. His father was an Englishman, a native of Lin- colMhire,^ who obtained a medical appointment early in life with the troops that served in Germany during the Seven Years' War. After the breaking out of the war of the French Revolution, he was appointed Surgeon- Major aiid head of the medical department in the garrison of Gibraltar, the duties of which he con- tinued to discharge until his death in 1801. Sir Hudson Lowe, the subject of the present memoir, was bom in the town of Galway on the 28th of July, 1769.* Shortly after his birth his father's regiment, the 50th, was ordered to the West Indies, and he was taken out with it. On his retum to England, and while still at school, before he had attained his twelfth year, he was appointed to an ensigncy in the East Bevon Militia, and actually passed a review in mili- tary uniform at that age. In the autumn of the year 1787 he obtained a King's commission as ensign in the 50th regiment, which was at that time stationed at Gibraltar, the Governor being the celebrated Sir George Augustus Eliott, afterwards created Lord Heathfield. " The works of the fortress," says Sir

* His ancestors had been settled for several generations in the county of liinoohi near Grantham. '

* Sir Hudson Lowe and Napoleon, therefore, were within one month of the same age.

86 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. IK.

Hudson Lowe, " were still in the most ruinous state from the effects of the siege. The whole rock was literally covered with fragments of broken shells and shot, and there was not a house in the town, nor a building within the batteries, which did not bear the marks of its devastation. Sir George Eliott was suc- ceeded in the command by General O'Hara, who pursued exactly the same course of discipline, with even an additional degree of personal zeal and acti- vity. . • • I was once proceeding with the escort in order to reach the barrier-gate by daybreak, and was moving with my head down, to stem, as well as I was able, the tremendous gusts of rain and wind which opposed me, when I heard myself very sharply spoken to by a mounted oflQcer, who desired me to * hold up my head, and look what I was about, for it was not as a mere matter of form I was ordered on that duty.' This officer was General O'Hara, who was on such occasions always the foremost to observe that the public duty was rightly performed. This was the ordy real rebuke I ever experienced from a superior officer during the whole course of my military life. I admitted its point as well as its justice, and am proud to believe the beneficial effect was not wholly lost upon me. I might cite instances of praise bestowed upon my conduct by the same distinguished officer, and even of services he afterwards rendered me ; but I relate only the above, because conveying what appears to me a really useful lesson. . . . Upon one occasion, at a guard mounting parade, it is in my recollection that some little innovation had been introduced by Prince Edward which did not happen to meet General O'Hara's ideas, and a reproof was conveyed to him in the hearing of the officers assembled. *I hope, Sir,' said Prince Edward, *I shall always do my duty.'

Chaf. m. MEMOIB OP 8IK HUDSON LOWE. 87

* And if you do not do so, Sir, I will make you do it,' was General O'Hara's reply."

After having been more than four years upon gar- rison duty, during which time, he says, every third or fourth night was passed on guard, with no other appliances for repose, between the reliefe of sentries, than a blanket upon boards and a pillow resting gene- rally upon a stone. Lieutenant Lowe obtained leave of absence, and travelled in France and Italy, whereby he acquired a proficiency in the languages of those countries, which was of singular use to him in after life. On his return to Gibraltar the war had broken out afresh, and he proceeded with his regiment to Cor- sica, where he was actively engaged in service until the 50th was ordered to garrison Ajaccio. The future Governor of St. Helena was thus quartered in the same town with the Bonaparte family, none of whom, however, he seems to have met. He says —

" We were all delighted with our change of quar- ters to Ajaccio. The town was well laid out, spa- cious^ well built, and the citadel had excellent accommodations, but not sufficient for all the officers. One of the best houses in the town was occupied by the mother and sisters of Bonaparte. The present General De Butts, of the Engineers, then a lieutenant in that corps, had been sent forward to provide quar- ters, and to intimate to the family that, as their sons were iB the French service, or had quitted the island, they must surrender their house for the use of the English garrison. An officer of the 60th, of the name of Ford, was for a short time quartered in their house, and spoke with much satislaction of the kind manner in which the family act«d towards him — the young girls, for such they were at that time, running slipshod about the house, but hardly any notice was taken of

88 CAPTIVITT OP NAPOLEON. Chap, UL

them. There were several balls and parties given shortly after our arrival there ; but Madame Bonaparte was not invited to them, on account of the situation of her sons. She soon after removed to Cargise, which had been originally a Greek colony, to a house which had been built or occupied by Count MarboBuf^ whilst at the head of the French administration in that part of the island. It is not from my own recollection I men- tion these circumstances, because, strange as it ma7 appear, I was not aware of the residence of any part of the Bonaparte family at Ajaccio during nearly two years we were in garrison in that town. I used fre- quently to hear Napoleon spoken ofi but not as con- nected with the exploit which has been generally mentioned as having given the first early celebrity to his name — his share, namely, in the expulsion of the British from Toulon. The person whom I most fre- quently recollect to have heard speak of him was Signer Campi, who at that time was employed in our Commissariat, and who afterwards, I have understood, acted as secretary to Joseph Bonaparte. Signor Campi used to speak to me with admiration of the intrepidity which he showed in shutting himself up in the building called the Seminary, with a body of the National Guards, and bidding defiance to the Royalist troops who were stationed in the citadel, and who thus became besieged there at the commencement of the Revolution. He also spoke of rather an unsuccessful operation which had been afterwards undertaken against the Maddalena Islands; but I heard not a word at that time of Toulon, which has since appeared to me rather extraordinary."

On the evacuation of Corsica, Lieutenant Lowe accompanied his regiment to Porto Ferrajo, in Elba. In 1795 he was promoted to a company; and was

C?HAP. m. MEMOIR OP SIR HUDSON LOWE. 89

soon after appointed Deputy Judge- Advocate to the troops. From Elba the 50th proceeded to Lisbon, and remained quartered nearly two years in Portugal, at Fort St. Juliens. At the expiration of that period it was ordered to Minorca, which was then commanded by General Fox, and to this island flocked a large body of emigrants fipom Corsica, who were organised into a small corps called the Corsican Bangers. With this body of troops Sir Hudson Lowe's fate and for- tunes became intimately connected.

The charge of the newly-raised corps was intrusted to him. Li August, 1800, being then about two hun- dred strong, they were sent to Gibraltar for the pur- pose of joining the expedition to Egypt under Sir Balph Abercromby. The command of tiie corps was given to Captain Lowe, with the temporary rank of Major; and it formed part of the reserve commanded by Major-General (afterwards Sir John) Moore. The army landed at Aboukir on the 8th of March, and the Corsican Bangers formed on the right of the Guards. The corps was warmly engaged, and sustained in several conflicts heavy loss. While in Egypt, Major Lowe sent his father, who was then Surgeon-Major to the garrison at Gibraltar, clear and detailed accounts of events as they occurred, but they are too well known to justify relation here.

He was present at the battle of Alexandria, on the 21st of March, 1801, and during the campaign was the means of saving Sir Sidney Smith's life. A picket having mistaken Sir Sidney for a French oflScer, from his wearing a cocked hat (the English army then wearing round hats), they levelled their pieces at him, when Major Lowe struck up their muskets, and saved him.

He received the first proposals for the surrender of

90 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. III.

Cairo, commanded the rear-guard of the escort to the French army on its march to Rosetta, and was present at the advances against and surrender of Alexandria.* His zeal and ability in command of the outposts, on various occasions, obtained for him this flattering encomium from General Moore, — "Lowe, when you're at the outposts, I always feel sure of a good night's rest."

And the same gallant and distinguished officer, when writing on the 27th of October, 1801, to Major Lowe's fether, thus spoke of the son : —

"In Sir Ralph Abercromby he lost, in common with many others, a good friend ; but, however, his conduct has been so conspicuously good, that I hope he will meet with the reward he merits."

Nor was the body of troops which he commanded one of which any leader need have been ashamed. Sir Robert Wilson, one of the historians of the campaign, bears strong testimony to their merits, saying of the Corsican Rangers, — " This corps in every action, and especially in the landing, distinguished itself particu- larly; and Major Lowe, who commanded it, gained always the highest approbation. Indeed it was a corps which, from its conduct and appearance, excited gene- ral admiration, and did honour to the nation of the First Consul of France."

On the evacuation of Egypt they returned to Malta, and at the peace of Amiens were disbanded; but

* In a letter to his father on the 28th of May, 1800, Major Lowe men- tioned the following instance of the heat of the climate : — " On the 23rd instant we had a strong specimen of the desert wind. The thermometer in the shade stood at 108 ; when exp(>8ed to the southern blast it rose to 120 ! No metal could be touched. Long Duncan, of the Hoyals, bnmt his fingers in taking his snuff-box. out of his pocket. It is now again become tolerably cool."

Chap. m. MEMOIR OF SIR HUDSON LOWE. 91

Major Lowe was confirmed in his rank as Major-Com- mandant from the 1st of July, 1800. He was then placed on half-pay ; and through the recommendation of Major-Greneral Moore was soon afterwards appointed to the 7th or Royal Fusiliers. Congratulating him upon this appointment, General Moore said, on the 21st of April, 1802, — *' It is nothing more than you well deserve ; and if I have been at all instrumental in bringing it about, I shall think the better of myself for

it I trust you will always consider me as a

person warmly interested in your welfare." Major Lowe remained at Malta from October 1801, until July 1802, during which time he was secretary to a Board for the adjustment of claims. He arrived in England towards the end of August ; and about May, 1803, through the influence of Greneral Moore, was appointed one of the permanent Assistants Quartermaster-Gene- ral. "I^" said Sir John Moore, on the 15th of June, " I have had the good fortune to get you employed in the way you wish, I am glad of it. I have known you a long time, and I am confident your conduct, in what- ever situation you are placed, will be such as to do honour to those who have recommended you."

Before Major Lowe had been many weeks in the west of England, he was sent by the Grovemment on a secret mission to Portugal, for the purpose of ascer- taining the military condition and resources of that country in the districts of Oporto, Viaiia, Valen9a, Chaves, Bragan9a, and Almeida. Having carefiiUy inspected those places, he reported favourably of the troops and defences, and expressed an opinion of the "practicability of defending the country by united British and Portuguese means." He returned to Lis- bon in September, and proceeded to the Mediterranean to raise another corps of Royal Corsican Rangers, of

92 CAPTIVITY OP NAPOLEON. Chap. HI.

which he was appointed Lieatenant-Colonel on the 31st of December, 1803.

After much difficulty he succeeded in raising his regiment, which formed part of Sir John Craig's expe- dition to Naples, in conjunction with some Russian troops ; and Lieutenant-Colonel Lowe commanded the advance of the army. The success of the French arms, however, and the approach of a powerful force under General St. Cyr and Marshal Massena, together with the withdrawal of the contingent of Russia, destroyed all hope of saving Naples, and the British troops re- turned to Sicily.

In May, 1806, the island of Capri surrendered to the squadron under Sir Sidney Smith ; and Sir John Stuart, who had succeeded Sir James Craig in the command of the army, determined upon sending Colo- nel Lowe, with five companies of the Corsican Rangers and a small detachment of artillery, to garrison the island, " feeling confident," said Sir John Stuart, in his instructions to him, " that these numbers, under the influence of your zeal and judgment, will suffice to maintain it against any eflForts of the enemy." He assumed the command of Capri on the 11th of June, and after the battle of Maida (at which part of his regiment was present) the whole of his corps was sent to join him in the island.

Early in August Sir John Moore arrived at Messina as second in command to General Fox. He visited Capri, where he and Colonel Lowe met for the last time. But their correspondence was fi-equent, and Sir John Moore's letters show his disgust at the intrigues of the Court of Palermo. In one of these he said, —

"Hitherto we have all of us perhaps, infected by Sir Sidney Smith, interfered too much in Sicilian poli- tics. For my part, I believe the more we keep aloof

Chap. IH. MEMOIR OP SIR HUDSON LOWE. 93

fh>m them, and confine ourselves to our military duties, the more we shall improve when it becomes necessary in affairs of real importance, and the less we shall be bespattered with the dirt of a very mean and intriguing court."

Colonel Lowe, however, was obliged to keep up a correspondence with Sicilian agents, more properly called spies, for the purpose of obtaining intelligence, and, amongst others, with a man named Suzzarelli, who seems to have acted the part of a double spy, and betrayed both sides whenever he had the opportunity. But his real character was well understood by Colonel Lowe, who took care not to intrust him with any information of importance.*

An event now occurred — the defence and loss of Capri — ^which, although Colonel Lowe's conduct at the time was warmly applauded by his superiors, became a convenient handle of attack to his enemies afterwards, and has been made the subject of reproach in a fisimous military history.' The &cts shall here

* A long story is related by O'Meara ( Voice from Bt, Helena, ii. 300-329), on the authority of Cipriani, Bonaparte's maltre-dlidtel, to the effect that Suzzarelli, while pretending to give information to the injury of the Neapo- litan government, was in fact an agent of Saliceti, the minister of war, and that Cipriani, then called Franchesd, was employed in assisting him to deceive Colonel Lowe. O'Meara's statement is full of errors in dates and facts. But, as has been weU observed in the * Quarterly Review' (No. LV., p. 230), " Suppose the whole story had been true, what would it amount to?— that SuzzareUi was a double spy, and took money and gave informa- tion on both sides." The English were not, however, such dupes in this matter as O'Meara and others have described them. Colonel Lowe told Mr. Elliot in August, 1806, that he was " long acquainted with Suzzarelli's diaracter :" that, not wishing to keep him at Capri, he had allowed him to retom to Naples, '* as his project involved no risk or expense to any one but himself."

• Napier's 'History of the Peninsular War,' vol, ii. 56. He says that it was at Capri *' Sir Hudson Lowe first became known to history, by lodng in a few days a post that, without any pretensions to celebrity, might hftve been defended for as many years." We cannot be surprised

94 CAPnVITT OF NAPOLEON. Chap. IU.

be shortly told, and the public can then judge for themselves.

In August Murat took possession of his kingdom, and soon after his arrival at Naples he determined to recover if possible the island of Capri. Sir John Stuart had deemed it necessary to strengthen the gar- rison ; but the only corps selected for that purpose was the Royal Malta regiment, which was then in a bad state of discipline. To this regiment, under the command of Major Hammill, the defence of Ana Capri (a part of the island with a fort of the same name to the west of the town of Capri, and separated from it by a valley or ravine) was intrusted, and the three companies of Corsican Rangers which had previously occupied that post were withdrawn. The total number of troops in Capri amounted to 1362, and, with the ex- ception of a small detachment of artillery (not exceed- ing nine men) and some oflQcers, the whole of these were foreigners.

The island of Capri * is three miles and a half long and about two miles in breadth at its broadest point, and it contained at this time 4000 inhabitants. The coast, except in a few places, is an inaccessible rock. Ana Capri stands on an elevated platform of rock which on the Capri side can only be ascended by a flight of more than five hundred steps, cut out of the stone. The few landing-places in Ana Capri are bad. The eastern extremity of Capri forms a strong position,

that Napoleon made this the subject of a sarcasm. One of his suite at St. Helena having remarked that ''Sir Hudson Tjowe could not forget Capri, where, with two thousand men and thirty pieces of cannon, mounted in the clouds, he was taken by twelve hundred French, commanded by the brave Lamarque, who could only reach him by the help of a triph escaladt^^^ Na o'con observed, " Well, Sir Lowe shows himself a better jailer than a good general." — Count Las Cases' Journal (Nov. 15, 1816).

^ Capri is the ancient Capre^e, famous, or rather infamous, as the retreat of the Roman Emperor Tiberias.

^^^H^.m. MEMOIB OF Sm HUDSON LOWE. 95

the land-front being secured on the right by perpendi- calar rocks, on the left by a rocky height on which is the castle, and in the centre by the city, the houses of which, being connected, form a continuous wall. The castle, which is on a commanding situation, could make a good defence against musketry, but not against can- non ; nor could this be remedied without rebuilding it from the foundation. In a letter written at the time by Colonel Lowe he said he considered 2190 men to be necessary for the defence of the island, and he had less than two-thirds of that number with him.

Early on the 4th of October 1807 the enemy's flotilla was seen steering for the island from Naples. Soon after- wards another division of vessels with troops, escorted by gun-boats, approached the back of the island from the direction of Salerno. The French expedition was commanded by General Lamarque, an officer of high reputation, and he had about three thousand troops under his command.

Supposing that the town of Capri was the enemy's first object, Colonel Lowe sent two companies of the Maltese regiment to assist the Corsican Rangers in defending the Marina Grande and adjacent places. The attempt of the enemy was repelled, and about noon they abandoned their design of attacking the Marina; and the principal division proceeded to the westward of Palazzo di Mare. The Maltese companies were consequently ordered to join their regiment in Ana Capri. The main hope of repelling the enemy consisted in preventing him from landing, and Colonel Lowe had felt confident that the Maltese regiment was fully capable of doing this ; but in fact little if any opposition was oflFered by that regi- ment to the disembarkation. Nearly two thousand troops were landed at Ana Capri ; and notwithstand-

96 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. HT.

ing the most strenuous efforts on the part of Major Hammill to encourage his men, the Maltese regiment gave way on the left, and dispersed themselves among the vineyards, while others had taken shelter from the fire of the gun-boats behind the stone walls which covered part of their position. The three companies of Corsican Rangers under Captain Church,* assisted by some companies of the Maltese, gallantly repulsed the enemy on the right, with great loss, in four suc- cessive attempts to advance ; but in the evening, being reinforced by* eight hundred men, the French com- pelled the Corsican troops to retreat, and General La- marque took possession of Ana Capri, and made prisoners the whole of the Maltese regiment which had acted with such pusillanimity.

Next morning a flag of truce brought a summons from Greneral Lamarque to Colonel Lowe to surrender the forts and batteries of Capri. He said, —

*' I hold a commanding position, and as soon as my artillery shall be placed I will destroy Capri, and it will be no longer time to negotiate. At this moment I may treat you with less severity."

To this Colonel Lowe gallantly replied, — " I acknowledge all the advantages which your pre- sent commanding positions afford you. Defence may therefore be more difificult, but it is not the less incum- bent on me. Your propositions of rigour or fitvour on such an occasion must be alike indifferent to an officer whose conduct will never be influenced by any other considerations than those of his duty."

A close siege now commenced, the details of which are minutely recorded in a journal of Sir Hudson Lowe. Here we can only state that Capri was vigor-

* Afterwards Lieutenant-Colonel Sir Richard Chuicb, C.B., G.C.H.

Chap. HI. MBMOIB OF SIR HUDSON LOWE. 97

ously attacked and bravely defended until it became evident that its commander could expect no reinforce- ments, and all hope of effectual naval aid from the British squadron had vanished.^

By the morning of the 15th the enemy had made a practicable breach, and, though every effort was used to fill it up, the rottenness of the materials and the rapidity of their fire rendered the task impossible* The besieged then attempted to raise a palisading behind, and an entrenchment above the breach, which was all that could be done, the tower to the right of it having been so much battered as to be in danger of felling. Meanwhile the French sharpshooters had established themselves so close beneath the walls as to enfilade all the salient parts. The enemy had suc- ceeded in placing a field-piece in the Governor's house within thirty paces of the walls, with which they kept up a fire, and the cannon of tibe besieged had been rendered unserviceable by the enemy's shot. Shortly before noon the French flotilla approached the Campar nella Point. At six in the evening Greneral Lamarque sent a flag of truce, bearing a summons to surrender, with an intimation that the General wished to have a personal interview with the English Commandant. Upon this Colonel Lowe arranged that hostilities should cease during the night, and agreed to confer with General Lamarque at his advanced post the next morning.

Accordingly, early on the 16th, Colonel Lowe pro- ceeded to meet the General. The latter demanded the immediate surrender of the place, and that the gar- rison should become prisoners of war, except only Colonel Lowe himself and five or six of his officeas,

* A fuller account of the siege will be found amongst the Letters an4 Documents at the end of the volume.

VOL. I. H

98 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLESON. Chap. m.

whom he would allow to retnm to Sicily. He ex- pressed his astonishment that they had not quitted the island instead of persisting in maintaining a post which was not tenable against cannon. Colonel Lowe replie^ that no distinction could be allowed between the troops and their commander or officers, and that the term ** prisoners of war " would not be admitted into any convention that might be framed. General Lar marque then proposed several modifications ; but Colonel Lowe positively refused to accept of any other condi- tions than to evacuate his post with arms and bi^age, and after his return to the town he drew up proposals for surrendering the island, and forwarded them to General Lamarque, who ultimately, and after some hesitation and difficulty, accepted them.^ On the 20th Colonel Lowe evacuated the town with his troops, and marched to the Marina, the place of embarkation, with all the honours of war.

It deserves to be mentioned, that, when General Lamarque required the restitution of several of the foreigners who had enlisted in the British service while prisoners of war. Colonel Lowe peremptorily refused. " You may shoot me, but I will never give up a single man," was his spirited reply to the Gene- ral's demand.

For the defence of the town of Capri the highest praise was bestowed upon its commander. After the fall of Ana Capri, and the loss of nearly six hundred out of less than fourteen hundred men, the surrender of the other part of the island, unless the enemy's sup- plies could be cut o£^ and the garrison received rein- forcements, seemed inevitable. With respect to Ana

' See the official report of the capture of Capri at the end of the volume, where some flattering letters addressed to C!olonel Lowe with reference to his conduct on that occasion are given.

Chap. JU. MEMOIB OF SIB HUDSON LOWE. 99

Gapii^ Colonel Lowe bad felt confident that the Mal- tese regiment would have repelled the landing of the enemy there as completely as he had repulsed their disembarkation at the town of Capri. In this expeo* tation he was deceived; and when enabled by the defeat of the enemy at Capri to proceed in person to Ana Capri, he learned to his surprise that it had not only fiJlen, but that the greater part of the Maltese regiment were prisoners. To recover that position wa3 utterly impossible; all that remained was to maintain his ground in Capri, but this was prevented by the want of all aid from the English squadron^ by which he had hoped that the island would be com-* pletely blockaded, and the enemy cut off from sup- plies. In this he was disappointed ; and when he drew np in a summary form fourteen causes to which he attributed the loss of Capri^ amongst them he reckoned as the prindpal, the want of vessels of war, the pro- ceedings of the British ships when they did arrive, and the conduct of the Maltese regiment.

Major-Qeneral Lord Forbes wrote to him and said^ '^ I am convinced that Sir John Stuart will take an early opportunity of expressing to you, as well as to the public, the sense he entertains of the unremitting zeal, ability, and judgment which your conduct has displayed under your late trying circumstances at Oapri ; and I have only to lament that your exertions, and those of the brave officers and men who supported you, have not been as sucoessM as they are honour- able to you and to them."

Some time after Colonel Lowe arrived in Sicily he felt much annoyed that his official report of the &11 of Capri was not published in the * London Gazette,' and, thinking that his professional reputation was at stake, he applied for leave to go to England to vindicate

H 2

100 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON, Chap. in.

himself from any imputation that might be attached to his character for the loss of the place. Indeed, at the time, owing to this circumstance and the unpleasant de* portment of Sir John Stuart towards him, he seriously contemplated retiring altogether from the army.

Sir John Stuart expressed " surprise at his wish to leave his regiment at the present moment " — ^alluding to its being about to form part of an expedition to the Bay of Naples ; but he said he should not oppose his desire if he considered that it was consistent with his professional duty to urge it. In reply, on the 14th of May, 1809, Colonel Lowe said that the peculiar cir- cumstances of the moment induced him to suspend his application for leave of absence, and to make a sacrifice of his private feelings on such an occasion. He there- fore remained in Sicily with the army.

In June the expedition alluded to sailed from Sicily for the Bay of Naples, the troops under the command of Sir John Stuart, and the squadron under that of Rear- Admiral Martin ; its object was to form a diversion in favour of our Austrian allies, by menacing the kingdom and capital of Naples. Fifteen thousand men were embarked, including the Corsican Bangers, under Colonel Lowe; and on the 24th the troops landed at Ischia, and Colonel Lowe did excellent ser- vice with his riflemen. The town was rapidly taken, and on the 30th the castle of Ischia surrendered, under a convention agreed upon between the French Com- mandant, and Colonels Lowe and St. Laurent on the part of the British authorities.

The Corsican Rangers returned to Sicily, and in September formed part of an expedition under the command of Brigadier-General Oswald, to drive the French from the islands of Cephalonia, Zante, Ithaca, and Cerigo. The ships anchored before the town of

Chap. in, MEMOIK OF SIBTflUbBOST'LO^k; ' ' ''' 101

Zaxite on the 1st of October ; and the next morning the first division of the troops, under the immediate orders of Colonel Lowe, eflfected a disembarkation, and tamed the defence of the town by cutting oflf its com- munication with the castle. The other division, under General Oswald, advanced towards the castle, and the enemy then accepted the terms which Colonel Lowe was directed to offer them, and surrendered the island. Cephalonia was next attacked, and submitted imme- diately. "I have," said General Oswald, in his despatch announcing its capture, "nominated Lieu- tenant-Colonel Lowe to the important duty of com- manding this island, certain that so delicate a trust could not be reposed in more able hands.'' Ithaca yielded on the 8th to a detachment under Captain Church, and Cerigo was taken a few days afterwards. The expediency of reducing the island of Santa Maura, which contained a strong garrison and was likely to become the rendezvous of a large force, strongly im- pressed itself upon Colonel Lowe's mind. His reasons convinced Greneral Oswald, and it was determined to make the attempt. On the 21st of March, 1810, troops were embarked in a squadron under the com- mand of Captain (afterwards Yice- Admiral Sir Gkorge) Eyre. The proceedings of the expedition are minutely detailed in a letter written by Colonel Lowe at the time, but it will be enough to quote General Oswald's despatch of the 24th of March, in which he says, " Lieutenant-Colonel Lowe commanded the advance, a portion of which (Greek light infiintry nnder Major Church) was kept upon the flank, and drove a party of Albanians from the adjacent heights. The town was found to be evacuated. . . . The enemy's flight was accelerated by a pre- viously concerted and extremely well-executed move-

102 '•(fAFfMW'Oi' NAPOLEON. Chap. HI.

ment of LieutenantrColonel Lowe with the rifles of his corps, supported by a company of the 35th and tw^o companies of the Royal Corsican Bangers. The party, headed by the Lientenant-Colonel, pushed along the narrow and perfectly exposed causeway which con- nects the town with the fortress. This unexpected advance led upon the enemy's rear, and contributed to his so quickly abandoning the strong redoubts, which a front attack alone could with difficulty effect/' The fortress of Santa Maura held out until the 16th of April, when it was agreed that the garrison should evacuate it with the honours of war, and be sent, as prisoners, to some British port, but that the officers should be allowed to return to Italy on their parole not to serve until exchanged. Santa Maura was made the presidency of a government comprising the islands of Cephalonia and Ithaca, which was intrusted to Colonel Lowe. In a circular letter announcing the appointment, General Oswald said he was confident " ttiat it would be most grateful to the Government and population of Cephalonia and Ithaca to know that they would still enjoy the benefits arising fix)m the civil administration of an officer who had shown himself the common father of all ranks and classes of their communities."

Colonel Lowe framed the provisional government, and presided over the civil as well as military admi- nistration of these islands for nearly two years, without ever claiming or receiving any remuneration for the extraordinary duties with which he was charged. Those duties were of a difficult nature, requiring temper, firmness, and administrative talents.

He was also frequently engaged in correspondence with the Turkish authorities on the coast of Albania and with the British Evident at Yanina. Sir John

Chap. m. MEMOm OF SIB HUDSON LOWE. 103

Stuart placed him in direct commimication with Ali Pasha, with whom he had a personal interview, and received an offer £rom him to land thirty thousand Albanians in Italy, to effect a diversion for the pur- pose of preventing the invasion of Sicily by Mnrat

On the 1st of January, 1812, lieutenant-Colonel Lowe obtained the rank of full Colonel, and in the following month was permitted to return to England on leave of absence. *^ I was then," he says, " in my twenty-fourth year of service, and had never been absent a single day fix)m my public duty since the commencement of the war in 1793. I had been in England only once during that time, and then only for a period of six months during the peace of Amiens/'

On the 9th of January, 1813, he was summoned to attend Lord Bathurst^ ttten Secretary of State for the War Department, and directed to proceed without delay to the north of Europe, to iospect a corps of troops called the "Russian-German Legion," which had been raised by the authority of the Emperor Alexander, and was composed of Germans who had deserted or been taken prisoners during the retreat of the French Army £rom Bussia. At the same time Liieut.-G«n. the Hon. Sir Alexander Hope was about to proceed to Sweden to conduct a negotiation, with the object of inducing the Crown Prince, Bemadotte, to co-operate with the Allied Powers, by the offer of a large subsidy and of compelling Denmark to cede Norway to Sweden.

It was intended to place the Bussian-Gkrman Le- gion under the command of Bemadotte, and a subsidy had been asked firom this country for its support But before this demand was complied with, the British Qoverument desired to ascertain the state and condi-

104 CAPTIVITY OF NAPOLEON. Chap. UI.

tion of the corps; and the task of obtaining this information was intrusted to Colonel Lowe.

After a stormy passage Sir Alexander Hope and Colonel Lowe arrived at Stockholm on the 11th of February. They had interviews with the King and Queen and the Crown Prince of Sweden, and met there Madame de Stael, a lady more celebrated than Bernadotte himself. Colonel Lowe thus describes in a letter both these remarkable persons : — " We were invited to an evening party at her house after dining with the Prince Royal, and had the pleasure of dining with her yesterday. Bonaparte's attempt against Bussia she treated with complete contempt ; address- ing herself principally to the Colonel of the Guards, who was the person sent to relieve the French officers who had been captured on the retreat from Moscow. A little theatre was formed in the house, and Madame de Stael, with her daughter, an extremely interesting girl in her sixteenth year, went through some of the finest scenes in Racine's tragedy of * Iphige'nie.' An old French officer who was present told me she surpassed Mademoiselle Clairon. After the tragic performance she, with her daughter, went through a lively piece of her own composition with infinite spirit, and her daughter performed a very graceful dance. The Prince RoyaJ entered soon, darting a glance at the company as he saw them collected in groups at small tables in the different rooms, and then glided away unperceived. I have never seen so remarkable a countenance as that of Bernadotte: an acquiline nose of most extraordinary dimension, eyes fiill of fire, a penetrating look, with a countenance darker than that of any Spaniard, and hair so black that the por- trait-painters can find no tint dark enough to give its right hue ; it forms a vast bushy protuberance round

Chap. in. MEMOIR OP SIR HUDSON LOWE. 105

his Read, and he takes great pains, I understand, to have it arranged in proper form.'*

Pursuant to instructions from Lord Cathcart, the British Ambassador at St. Petersburg, Colonel Lowe proceeded to join him at the head-quarters of the Smperor Alexander at Kalisch in Poland, and in passing from Memel to Kdnigsberg he crossed the river Niemen upon the same raft on which the memo- rable conference was held between Napoleon and the Emperor Alexander, after the battles of Eylau and Finland.

He had an interview with the Emperor, and found that the corps of which he was in pursuit was between Narva and Konigsberg, scattered over an extent of more than five hundred miles. After performing the duty of inspection he had the opportunity of being an eye-witness of